How Do You Pray When God's Answer Is No? | 10@9 | 2026.11.20
Dieser Inhalt ist noch nicht ausgewertet.
Wortlaut anzeigen
Good morning. Today is Friday, November 20, 2026. Early in our Torah portion of Vayetzeh, the Torah tells us that Lavon has two daughters, Rachel and Lea. Lea is older, Lea and Rachel. And the Torah tells us that Aene Lea Rakhos. Lea's eyes were Rakhos. Now, there are many different translations of this word Rakhos and many suggestions of what it means. But the Talmud says, I guess the best word to translate it in English would be that Lea's eyes were puffy. The Talmud says, because she was constantly crying. She was constantly crying. And so when you look at a person that's been, God forbid, crying for a long time, their eyes are puffy. Why was she crying? So the Talmud says that when Yaakov and Asav were born, they were twins. Around the same time, Rachel and Lea were born. They were also twins. And the families, although they live far apart from each other and probably had not even met each other, but they sent messages back and forth. We had twin boys. We had twin girls. And the Talmud says that as children, there was an arrangement between the two families that the oldest would marry the oldest and the youngest would marry the youngest. So that means that Asav would marry Lea and Yaakov would marry Rachel. And it was kind of just an arrangement in the families that one day when the time comes, this is how it will work. But the problem was that Lea soon learned about the character of Asav, that he was such an evil and wicked person as Arabis describe him, a Russia doing every kind of sin. The opposite of the kind of life, the diametric opposite of the kind of life that Lea wanted to live for herself, a life of holiness, a life of beauty, a life of spirituality. And she prayed to Hashem that this would not happen. And she prayed with tears for years and years she prayed, even though it was a plan, even though it was so to speak arranged, but she prayed that it would be overturned, that it would change, that it would be different. And then Yaakov comes to the family and Yaakov falls in love with Rachel and love on agrees that Yaakov can marry Rachel, the younger daughter. And so now it appears even more serious that Lea is fated to be married to this terrible wicked person, Asav. But she continues to pray, she does not give up praying. We learn a tremendous lesson about the power of prayer she did not give up praying the entire seven years that Yaakov was working in order to be able to marry Rachel. Lea was praying that somehow it would turn out she would not have to marry Asav, somehow. And it appeared hopeless because Rachel is engaged to Yaakov. And this idea that Rachel to Yaakov and Lea to Asav has been decades in everyone's mind, it's completely hopeless. And Rachel, Lea, Lea, I'm sorry, Lea still prays and davans and cries for it, for it not to happen. And finally God put some crazy idea in the mind of love on to switch at the wedding night. Lea for Rachel, Amaravina, Ravina says in the Talmud, you see that intense prayer, genuine prayer with tears has the power, the potential to overcome a decree to make the impossible happen. From Lea we learn koach at filah, the power of prayer. But sometimes, you know, in spite of our prayers, we don't get the response we want. And then prayer has to take on a different role after the fact. Somehow prayer now has to help us respond. It has to help us cope with the devastating disappointment. How do we live with that? A number of years ago, I think it was about 12 or 13 years ago, there was a terror attack in Israel in the northern part of Israel is a terrible, terrible thing. There was a husband and wife with children in the back seat, they were driving and they were attacked by terrorists. The husband and wife, the father of the children and mother of the children, they were shot and killed with their children in the back seat. Children witnessed this. Now, it doesn't matter who it happened to. I mean, it's a horrible tragedy, a terrible, terrible thing no matter who it is, but it happens that the young man was a noted Torah scholar, as was his wife. And the parents of the young man are quite well known. The father of this young man was Rev. Yehuda Henkin. Zichron Levocha, since then he has passed away. But he was a great Torah scholar. He wrote, responds him. He was a teacher, well regarded authority on Jewish law. And the mother of the young man is Rabanit Kana Henkin. I've mentioned Rabanit Henkin to you before. She is one of the greatest teachers of Torah today in the world. She is largely responsible single-handedly for the beautiful and amazing surge in advanced Torah learning by women in our generation. She started Nishmat and many other initiatives. And Nishmat itself has many different initiatives. I've had the great privilege, the honor to meet her a couple of times. She is one of my absolute heroes in this world today. Rabanit Henkin. A couple of years after the tragedy, so this is maybe about 10 years ago, the two of them, Rabbi Henkin and Rabanit Henkin, they came to the annual convention of the RCA, the Rabbinical Council of America, and they spoke to us about their tragedy. And specifically their topic was how they responded to the terrible traumatic tragedy that happened to them through prayer. They spoke about prayer in the aftermath of this terrible, terrible, terrible thing. Rabanit Henkin was riveting. I don't think I'll ever forget what she said, how she said it, it was. And so I want to try in a very diluted way to paraphrase a little bit of what she said to try to convey just a tiny bit of the power and the strength with which she spoke. She said, you know, catastrophe after prayer, unanswered. When there's a catastrophe and people are praying and in this case, they were seriously injured, people were praying for their recovery. And there was great intensity and because the Henkins were so well known, there were people all over the world praying for their children and their grandchildren. And there were such prayers all over the world. And and Rabanit Henkin said, in that kind of situation, and there have been others we could think of, it feels as if the heavens are pierced with the prayers coming from all sectors of the Jewish people to beg God that their lives should be saved. And when there is such an outpouring throughout Klaw Israel, there is an Achtos, there is a unity that comes from the fact that everybody in the world, all over the world, religious secular in Israel, outside of Israel, left, right, everyone is joining together in this intense prayer for this cause. And then if God forbid, the response to the prayers is not what we would like to be. And the worst happens. Then there is a terrible, terrible letdown, energy wanes. There's a sense of being rebuffed by God, God forbid. And it's a spiritual step backwards for many people. Rabanit Henkin said to us, just again riveting, she said to us, she had no philosophical problem with prayer after the death of her children. Her faith was not shaken. She had an emotional problem because of her shattered hopes, her betrayed expectations. Emotionally, she was shattered, but philosophically, theologically, nothing had changed for her. And she explained to us, and I will try to convey to you very briefly her thinking. One of the most famous prayers that we utter, and we've discussed this so many times, Ms. Marla David, a song of David, Hashem Rui, lo-exar, God is a shepherd, God is my shepherd, lo-exar, I don't need anything. I'm not lacking anything. And one of the famous lines in this famous paragraph of De Hillan, Ach to vach esed yedafuni koyemeh hayay, Only good and kindness should pursue me all the days of my life vashavdi bevesa Hashem lo-orach yamim, and I should be able to dwell in the house of God forever. Surely goodness and kindness will follow me all the days of my life. Revenit Henkin said to us, there are two problems. Number one, it's not true. It's not an accurate view of life. It is not correct that goodness and kindness follows us all the days of our lives. We pray for it, we wish for it, but every single one of us knows individually, and we certainly know as a people, that's not how life works. Often, goodness and kindness do not follow us. They do not pursue us. Sometimes tragedy and pain and loss and trauma pursue us. And secondly, she said, it's not an accurate translation of the words. The words don't say that. Ach to vach esed yedafuni koyemeh hayay accurately translated means that I should pursue goodness and kindness all the days of my life. It's not a promise. If it was a promise, it would be a broken promise. It's not an accurate promise, but it's not a promise. It's a challenge. It's a challenge that I am to pursue goodness and kindness that you were to pursue goodness and kindness all the days of your life. It's a challenge because that's what life is. Life is a series of challenges. That is what life is. Not a promise. I learned from Revenit Henkin in Israeli idiom. I mentioned this to some people before. Doed shels sukaryot. Literally that means an uncle with candy. You know in many synagogues, here we call it the candy man. They're people that come to shul with a bag of candy and their job, their role is to give out a piece of candy to all the children in shul. All right. Sometimes the parents complain it's too much candy. Okay, fine. I do this when at the end of davening at a dath on Shabbat's morning, the children come up to all together sing the end of davening and adon alam at the very ending. And all the children that come up to sing adon alam, they come up to the bima. I give them a piece of candy. It's the best part of my job. It's the absolute best part of my job. And in that moment, I am a doed shels sukaryot. Right? I'm the candy man for that minute. Doed shels sukaryot. Revenit Henkin said to us, God is not doed shels sukaryot. God's job is not to hand out treats to us. That's not the way this world is set up. And if you think God is a doed shels sukaryot handing out treats to you all the time, you will be sorely disappointed. So if the basis and goal of our prayer is that I should be safe and happy. And of course that's our request, right? We have all these prayers that I should have good health and I should have enough to eat and all the things we ask for, of course we want these things to happen. And yes, for sure, it can be the result of our prayers that we will be answered the way we want, like Leo was, that is an outcome of the prayers that we offer that is possible. But if that's what we expect from prayer, we will be disappointed. And I think every single one of us in our own lives, I certainly, but I think every single one of us has had occasions when we have prayed very hard for a specific outcome that meant a lot to us. And the answer, nebih was no. And certainly events in the world, especially over the last few years, but over the last centuries, thousands of years, if that's our understanding of prayer, the expectation that we should get what we ask for, then we're going to have a real problem with prayer. And it is true, we've discussed this many times, prayer for many of us, especially when we've had an experience like this becomes much more difficult. I can tell you from where I sit, the number of people who tell me they don't come to shul because they prayed for something and it didn't happen. They prayed for someone to get better and they didn't, they prayed for something to happen. So what's the purpose of prayer? So Abeneed Henkin says as follows, the historical earliest basis of prayer is tahanunim, is bakasha, supplication, requests. If you look in Buresh's, in the Torah, Yitzchak and Rivka pray to God that they should, that Rivka should have a child. Eliezer prays to God that he should find a mate for Yitzchak over and over and over again, a prayer to receive something. And for centuries this was the paradigm of prayer. Why is that so important? Even if sometimes it doesn't happen? Well, because it expresses our dependence on God, I recognize that everything comes from God. So I have to pray to God for good health, I have to pray to God for success, I have to pray to God for safety and security. And with that comes an expectation that God watches over us. But all too many of us with what has happened to us individually, what happens to us as a people, we become jaded and this becomes a problem for us. And all too often we don't feel ourselves in the hands of God. And so Abeneed Henkin said we need a new, a different paradigm for prayer. And she explained and we've discussed this before many times, but she puts it in a different context that later in our history after the destruction of the Beitah M'gadosh, the Holy Temple in Jerusalem, they're developed a new paradigm of prayer, prayer when it becomes a substitute for a carbon for a sacrifice. When the Beitah M'gadosh was destroyed, there were no longer sacrifices, prayer became the substitute. How does that work? We've explained this before. The Ramban explains that the word Karban comes from the word Karev. To offer a sacrifice is a gesture of coming closer to God. And in its place, prayer helps us to accomplish the same goal, to come closer to God. Prayer expresses our yearning to come closer to God, not for what God will give us, but simply to yearn to be closer to holiness, simply to remove ourselves for a while from the world of uncertainty and enter a place where our soul can connect with its source with God. That's the goodness and kindness that we encounter through prayer. That's the comfort that prayer can realistically and meaningfully give us, not that I'm going to get what I ask for, although that's what I hope and that can happen. But even when that answer is no, prayer fulfills its role of bringing me closer to God. A prayer is never wasted. Even a request denied is not wasted, because the primary purpose of the request is not the response. It's the connection to God, God, I depend on you. God, you're in control. God, I'm in your hands. That's the primary purpose of the requests that we make. It's the connection to God, the connection to holiness. When the answer is no, emotionally it will be very, very hard. No question. But philosophically, that is what we are challenged to do in life. Ach to vach esed. We are to pursue goodness. And the goodness and the kindness we are challenged to pursue, call yeme hayay, all the days of my life, is to pursue, of course, goodness and kindness to others. Yes, of course. But also to pursue through prayer, the goodness and kindness that comes with kharav, with karban, with coming closer to God, so that the ultimate goal of prayer is the last line. V'shav ti bev'ez ha'shem, call yeme hayay. May I dwell in the house of God all the days of my life. That's the purpose of prayer. And although it may be emotionally difficult after tragedy and catastrophe, but philosophically, theologically, this is what prayer can do to comfort us in the aftermath of that catastrophe. To recognize that prayer can bring us closer to God even now, I would say especially now, we're called upon to pursue prayer, to come closer to God, so that we can dwell with God all the days of our life. Thank you, Reban Ithenkin, for your uniquely incredible contributions to the Jewish people. And thank you, Reban Ithenkin, for sharing with us such personal reflections that will allow all of us to understand prayer differently and to allow it to have the deepest meaning in even the most difficult times of our lives. My friends, I wish you a great Shabbos, a beautiful day, a beautiful Shabbos. And I look forward to seeing you soon in person.