Skip to content
omnism.si

Zen · Compare this tradition with another

Open Dharma: Nonviolence and Our Moral Imperative

Upaya Zen Center Santa Fe - Dharma Podcast · Upaya Zen Center Santa Fe - Dharma Podcast · 2026-11-09 · Santa Fe · Source

This text has not been analysed yet.

Show the full text
Thank you for listening to UPIA's Dharma Podcast, an extraordinary series of talks from some of the finest teachers in the world. I'm Joan Halifax, founder of the UPIA's End Center, and we're happy to make these podcasts available to you. Please consider making a donation so we can offer these recordings freely. You'll find a donation button on our podcast page. And thank you so much. This is Dharma Podcast at DharmaPodcast.org I want to be sure that you can hear in the back. Okay, good. Thank you so much. How was last night for you? I actually had decided to talk about lineage, but after last night, I do want to make a few, offer a few remarks about what many of us experienced, actually anybody in this country experienced, but also I've received communications from Brazil, from friends in Serbia, and actually people all over the world who are in Canada and Japan and more. We're expressing a lot of respect for our solidarity, which is the turnout for this election. Because many of us, including myself, have felt a profound concern about the violence and violation of rights in our country. And no matter on what side of the so-called divide you stand, any kind of violence and injustice affect you. Because we are one body, no matter what our thoughts or ideas bring us to. And not only we are one body as a community with independence and MAGA and Democrats and Republicans and conservatives, and I don't know. But we're one body with this earth. And actually this is something that I feel very deeply about, and that is the violence that the natural world continues to experience, really since the onset of the agrarian era, many, many, many years ago, but the increasing violence toward our earth. And its effects on our lives and the lives of all species. I did experience last night not only relief, but we know that reformation, reformations take a lot of work. And the relief that many of us experienced, and I'm sure that we have people who voted different than I did, differently than I did in this room and online. And I really respect that you showed up to vote. You're voting your values. But I also, the feeling that I had was not just relief, but also the importance of commitment to actually engage in shifting the deeper values in our country. Values that are built on capitalism that is fundamentally extractive and that has been in operation for a very long time. And also, I recently saw a remarkable film called Ghost in the Machine. Has anyone seen that film? I really encourage you to see it because it is a very deep analysis of the roots of artificial intelligence in our country, which surprisingly enough come out of the Nazi-ism, excuse me, out of fascism, eugenics. It's really fascinating. Ghost in the Machine, it's on PBS and it's clearly accessible. As some of you know, I've been a consultant to various Buddhist groups presenting and various who are concerned with the effects of artificial intelligence, large language models, ASIs and so on. It's an alphabet. Very concerned about the effects, not only on our human relations and how we actually begin to cultivate the mind of connection, not disconnection, but also the effects on our environment. And I've been heavily criticized, by the way, for these seemingly more sectarian views, views that are political and have to do with justice and I would say care. And one of the things that I think is very important that we as citizens of this country and of the world, we have a responsibility to cultivate the quality of mind and also the character that is able to stand in your strength and the strength of what you consider to be an experience as nonviolence, nonviolence. Which is a term that covers a tremendous amount of territory from our own inner violence in terms of our thoughts to the violence that we engage in and how we handle objects to the violence in our economy where the 1% is getting even smaller but has bigger bank accounts and where people who are fleeing from violence in their countries are treated with equal, if not greater, violence than ours. We have to ask who are we, really? What is important now? What are we willing to stand for? What are we willing to send our voice and to risk our own safety at a time when we're not just in a small neighborhood on the prairie somewhere but we are all global citizens and we're all inhabitants on this earth. I feel very strict about this inside of myself because of the sense of moral dilemmas that I personally experience every day when I turn on the water to brush my teeth and then forget to turn it off as I'm continuing to brush my teeth. Because it's not only in the big acts of our lives, of our institutions that we create such as this, which is a small institution but one that stands for a set of values related to justice, related to compassion, related to respect, but also the institutions that we engage in as individuals and as institutions, including our own government, where the values at the onset were clear and those are reflected in our constitution. But our constitution has been in a certain way discarded. So coming here to you, Paya, whether you're a resident, a staff member, a visitor, a learner, a practitioner, whatever has brought you to this institution, to this organism because we're not only an institution, it is essential that you understand what the vision is here and what the mission is here. And that is to create the conditions where you can awaken to the edges that you have not recognized, that you have been standing on, that you have been falling over, and to actually learn how to be upright, a person of integrity at a time when integrity is compromised in so many quarters. And then you have the strong back of equanimity, which means that you're able to uphold yourself in the midst of any conditions. Where you're not hijacked by your emotions, nor turning away from them because you have a soft front as well, an open front to the complex realities that are part of your internal experience, your own subjectivity, but also the intersubjectivity of your lived experience as well. I look at UPAIA and maybe it is not that for some, but that would be regrettable for me because NOAA indicated this has been a tremendous work of 36 years of bringing this institution into being with many people who had faith in this vision of what it is to be an upright person, a true human being, a person of moral and caring character in a complicated world. It's not a place for personal improvement. It's a place to awaken to the sense of responsibility that good human beings have in experiencing, not just seeing, experiencing the suffering in the world, whether it's suffering in the trees, the seas, the wildlife, the birds, or that man who, outside of your window, who made it here from Mexico or El Salvador or Nicaragua, who is afraid that he's going to be plucked from this life by ice. I've said on various occasions that this endo would not be here for two amazing men from Chihuahua, who during the pandemic, which is when we started this project, and thanks Mark and also the contractor bringing these two men who had not that much experience in building, so it was a longer project than we had anticipated. But look at this place. And look at almost every building and every landscape in Santa Fe. Somebody from the South is responsible for that happening. Take this not for granted. And we're turning these people and harming these people and throwing these people into super-harms way, person after person, child after child. So every time I walk into this space or into any space at Upaya, somebody from the South has made that space beautiful. It's to know the roots of things, including lineage. Lineage is important. Now, there is discussion in certain Buddhist communities about the inappropriateness for Buddhists to be involved in such questions. And I would suggest that that is probably not even aligned with the Buddha. What is interesting if you look at what the Buddha studied in terms of the governmental structures that he established within his own community 2,500 more last years ago were learned from his exploration of the Vijayan Republic. I made a few notes about this, and I just want to share some of these thoughts with you. Let me access them. So some of the things about this Vijayan Republic, and I really encourage you to study it because many people don't know that this is in a way the example of an early democracy in the Indian continent that became the model for the sangha that we now practice in today. People in the Vijayan Republic met often, brought people together frequently. And this goes to this vision, by the way, of Terry Tempest Williams' book, The Open Space of Democracy. And Veronica Roe's work, who's a lawyer who looked at what's happened more very often in our own culture with the destruction of the commons, particularly through the world of technology, the parks, the libraries, the movie theaters. And I would say also this is a commons, just as CVS is also a commons, just as your local restaurant that you don't necessarily order from in order to get your food, but you sit in and kind of feel other people in the space is also a commons. Meeting often in the space with others is really critical. And it is something that we endeavor to practice here in the resident community by virtue of being in a practice space and in a learning space and in a living space that is fundamentally communal, and eating space as well. It's warm hand to warm hand. It's presence to presence. And this is really critical because something in our society began to break apart when extended families became a possibility and a small nuclear family took over and now it's amping up even more through technology and also by people, not even coupling, many people choosing to actually live alone and only having techno commons to relate to. Commons requires presence. Commons requires, commons require embodiment. In the Vigian Republic, decisions were made not by the avid, not by the president. They were made together in a democratic form. And their traditions supported that and were deeply respected. There were also important guidelines in the Vigian Republic about protecting the vulnerable, the sick, children, the elderly, and so forth. I wrote something earlier today reflecting on this remarkable midterm. Really, I've been following politics since I was very, very young. I would say about 10 years old. I was quite sick when I was a child. And then I became subtly politicized. And so at 10 years old, I breathe. That's a mindfulness bell, but we like to have you turn it off. Smile. Thank you. Who's the miscreant? Will you take responsibility that is part of the practice to understand that an unsilenced phone affects all of us? Really, an unsilenced or flapping mouth affects all of us for better or for worse. Okay. Don't worry. No shaming, but just correction. But it is a beautiful example. Here we are in a commons and we made a request because we want to create the optimal conditions for you. And then there you are. There we are. This happens all the time. Our lives are filled with moments of going off the rails or maybe not realizing that in fact our phone has not been muted. Oh, dear. But it does just a simple thing like that affects the whole space. Just imagine. Just imagine. It's what some of the things that have happened in our country. The murder of Renee Good and of Alex Petty. This affected all of us. All of us. Things really matter, both great and both small. So it is one of the reasons why we try in, you know, I'm going off on a tangent, but I'll get back on. You know, we endeavor at UPIA to create the conditions where people can understand that the violation of rights of boundaries of vows of agreements affects all of us. And that we have fundamentally collective responsibility to engender safety, integrity, accountability and harmony in the spaces that we inhabit, which are not just human led, but also include this room, the trees outside and so forth. Harmony with the world that supports us, including the trees, the meadows and everything in the natural world. So I was recently with and will soon be again with just a wonderful human being. You're wonderful too. She's really wonderful. She is the writer, Terry Tempest Williams. And I have to tell you, she is brilliant, but funnier than almost any person I know. I won't repeat some stories about her, but I'm glad that we'll be with her. She'll be here coming in on the 13th of November. She's written a quite beautiful book, a kind of exploration. The book is called The Open Space of Democracy. It's a small book. And she writes that democracy like wilderness depends on open space. And again, going back to Monica Roe, if any of you have read some of my essays on solidarity, open space, we would call also commons, room for many voices, room for disagreement, and also for ideas, thoughts, visions, perspectives, room where they can actually circulate freely. And we're going to have someone here along with Terry, Molly Crockett, a cognitive scientist from Princeton University who directs the Crockett Lab, who addresses this very important point, that in order for communities to be strong, difference and differences need to be present. And we have to build across those differences. And we have to build from difference. Terry goes on to say that it's especially important for us to protect open land. And I want to say something to our credit here at UPIA. If you look at the face of Cerro Gordo Mountain over 36 years, small sliver of land after small sliver of land, we have bought the entire face and protected the entire face of Cerro Gordo Mountain. Very few people know that. Why? They wanted us to cut trails through there. I became unpopular in the neighborhood and said, no, we need open space in democracy. We need open space in wilderness. We need to understand. We need open space for the wildlife, which now seems to have inhabited UPIA more thoroughly and decimated our squash plant for harvest, but nonetheless. Open space gives everything space to breathe, space to be. We've also, over the years, protected the Bosque, not just below us, but both to the east and to the west of us. Areas in the Bosque that could have been developed, built on. And we've concentrated our building on these few flat places that in the early, late 19th century, early 20th century, were bean fields. So we built on bean fields here, but nothing else. Not removing trees, but actually planting. Not only one tree, but now hundreds of trees on the lands that we steward. Terry is saying that the open space of democracy is where people can speak, where they can experience dissent, difference, and most importantly, where they can really listen to each other, where they can hear each other. And I feel that is, in a way, the most important element. Developing the capacity to hear deeply. My beloved teacher, Glassman Roshi that Kodo mentioned, I was so grateful I met Bernie in the 70s and became his formal student in the mid-90s after he and Jishu went to the capital, D.C. in January, and he was 94, something around that. And in the snow, sat a bearing witness retreat with a few close students, because they realized being in this wonderful place they had just outside of New York City didn't fit with who they were. And they wanted to see in terms of the road ahead, particularly in light of the Bush administration, what really needed to happen. And they decided to start the Zen Peacemaker Order. And the heart of that order involves three tenets, the Tenet of Not Knowing. That tenet talks about this ability to be radically open, to not be caught in the filtration of your own views, of your knowing, of your education, of your certainty, of your security. But as so many people refer to, to be in this kind of beginner's mind, to be able to listen in such a way that you don't immediately throw out or throw away what another person is saying. And even if what they're saying points toward violence, which was my experience of working in the prison system years ago, even if what they're saying is pointing toward violence, to hear deeply and to listen deeply, to understand the roots, the lineage that this person came from, of an economically deprived, racially threatened, violent, drug addicted family and so forth. Not knowing. And the second tenet is Bearing Witness. By bearing witness, actually it is this experience of not separating from whatever is being or arising in the moment. It's a kind of expression of samadhi, non-separation, of not pushing away the issue, the person, the violence. There is a line that I often quote from the Denku Roku Zen Master, which is on wonderful teachings on the successive awakening of our lineage, in the transmission of light. And it's a line that puzzles some people. And actually I was reviewing Unfinished Vow. I'm scraping through chapters. And I love this line so much because people don't get it at first. It was really funny. I wrote it three times so far. I'm only into page 60, so it's shown up. I wrote it three times so far in the preceding chapter. It's not realizing it. I already said it. But anyway, I'm really fond of this line. And I think it's in Francis Cook's translation, by the way. And Kezon, by the way, came after Ehedoken and is kind of known as the mother of the soto sect. He made soto practice much more accessible and more related to the indigenous traditions of Japan. And the line is, do not find fault with the present. And you're like, what? Why do you think that? What are you, you know, da-da-da. All the stuff that our administration's been doing, or my husband, or, you know, that resident, whatever it is. But actually what Kezon in that line is suggesting is quite interesting. The present is the present as it is. It is not to say we don't call for accountability. It's not to say that we don't work for justice. But in order to bear witness, you cannot bear witness through the filter of finding fault with things that as they are. It's really an interesting poke, if you will. Bearing witness is being absolutely present to the truth of suffering, or the truth of joy, or craziness, or whatever it is. As it is, without our judgments, our disagreements, our views, our fears filtering, being fully present, bearing witness. The second tenant. And then Bernie and his wife, Tishio Anguio Holmes, had a third tenant. And that tenant is compassionate action. Because out of not knowing and bearing witness, compassionate action is possible, not before. Anything that is viewed through the filter of our desires or fears is prescriptive in terms of the action that we might take. What is it, and I've written about this quite a lot, if you've read my piece on inactive compassion. Forgive me, I'm still jet lag, so. What is it to see clearly in an unfiltered way, without the filters of our fears, without filters of confusion, without our small hope life, not wise hope life, without our version mediating. But to see things clearly as they are. And that is really the point of our practice. To familiarize ourselves sufficiently with our subjectivity. And the fact is that it's constructed. Our sense of a separate self is a notion. That is constantly preventing us from being truly present. Going back to Terry's wonderful book of these collected essays. You know our constitution puts great emphasis on the value of freedom. But also our constitution doesn't begin with I the person. It begins with what? We begin with the world. Yeah. They could add a few more phrases like we the people and all sentient beings and non sentient ones as well. Freedom is this experience of actualizing our interconnectedness with all beings and things. And that at this very moment, our lives are often, also not often, are also being worked by things that we aren't even immediately in touch with, but that are happening simulta