Donald Rothberg: Compassion, Equanimity, and a Contemporary Vision of Our Practice
This text has not been analysed yet.
Show the full text
Good, so thank you so much. And I want to talk today giving a kind of contemporary vision of our practice, and particularly focusing on what we explored in the guided practice, namely the development of equanimity and the development of compassion. And I'll just say that I'm returning now from traveling and teaching. I just got home three days ago, and I was away for four and a half weeks. And the first place I was, was I was about three weeks in the mountains of North Carolina. We can show that image. Christina. I was teaching at Southern Dharma, teaching a two-week retreat. And this is, we'll see, this is where I was. I was in the mountains for about three weeks, about two weeks, teaching a two-week retreat, and then about six days with a personal retreat, which is very, very, very wonderful. And we can let go of the slide. And so I'm really, yeah, I also taught in Louisville, Kentucky. And then I went to Washington, D.C. to visit relatives. And I grew up in that area to see what was happening in Washington, although not all of it. I would have been open to a counseling session with the president, but it didn't materialize. Oh, well. Might have changed world history, but didn't happen. Okay, so, so, the question I'm asking is, at a time of great challenges in the world especially, what kind of practice is called for? You know, how can we really hold our practice? And I'll be emphasizing a lot the importance of equanimity and compassion in these times. I'll keep coming back to that. But I'm going to ask that question generally. How do we both ground in tradition and respond to the needs of our time? I think that's what it means to be part of any tradition. And so we can make use of Buddhist tradition and probably some of us ground in multiple traditions. How many people ground both in Buddhist practice and maybe some other traditions? No, so several people. You know, and I think that can be very important. You know, I've been reading a lot of wonderful author named Murabai Starr, who describes herself as interspiritual. Some of you may know her work. I've mentioned it from time and time. Interspiritual, and she says, what does interspiritual mean? It means I have dedicated practices, but not just in one tradition and multiple traditions. So I think for some of us that can be a very important practice now. And I was thinking of this grounding in tradition, but responding to the needs of our time in relationship to one of the places I also went to during my travels. I taught in Louisville, Kentucky, and I spent the greater part of the day about an hour south of Louisville at the Abbey of Gethsemane, where Thomas Merton was a monk. How many people know the work of Thomas Merton? He often thought to be the most important Christian contemplative of the 20th century. And let's go to the next images. First showing an image of Merton. This is Thomas Merton. He died in 1968. Actually in Asia, he made a trip to Asia, met the Dalai Lama. This is him in front of his hermitage near the monastery, and he lived there for the last five years. And I've visited there and actually done gatherings at the hermitage at times. The next image is an image of the monastery itself. This is the Abbey of Gethsemane. Really welcomes visitors. One can do retreats there. And I think a lot of openness to... people from different traditions. I started visiting there in the 1980s when I was teaching at the University of Kentucky about an hour away. I would go there about every two or three weeks. And I was part of a group called the Thomas Merton group, which met with monks and nearby nuns from the Sisters of Loretto. About 10 or 15 people. And this time, I met... let's go to the next slide. I met with this is brother Paul, who is almost 86, who has been a friend. I met him over 40 years ago. And we've stayed in touch. I always, you know, when I go to teach in Kentucky, I visit with him. He was a student of Merton. And he was probably something like the Merton of our time. He's written, published several books of poetry, several other books, wrote a memoir recently called In Praise of the Useless Life. Brother Paul Khenon, wonderful, wonderful being. And we're probably going to teach next year in Louisville, do something on Buddhist and Christian meditation, something together. So we can let go of the slides now. And I wanted to read a quotation from Merton about this way that we ground in tradition, but we look to what, how we meet the needs of the present time. Again, it's a nice framework to have. This is from Thomas Merton, I think, from 1965. And, you know, he was quite, even though he was a monk, he was very aware of what was happening in the world. At that time, he was writing about the Civil Rights Movement, for example. This is Merton. Tradition is not passive submission to former generations' interests, but a living ascent to a current of uninterrupted vitality. Fidelity to tradition does not mean the renunciation of all initiative, but a new initiative that is faithful to a certain spirit of freedom and a vision which demands, which demands to be incarnated in a new and unique situation. I found that very, very clear. You know, we stay true to the core of the tradition, but we also respond to how this tradition can meet the present moment and the present times. So I'm going to suggest that as a good, simple way to frame how our practice is. And I wanted to remember the three forms of our practice, really taught by the Buddha. This is remembering the core of our practice, is our training in wisdom and meditation and in ethical practice. Those are the three dimensions of training that I talk about, if I'm not, that make up the three dimensions of the noble eightfold path. I think we know there are two aspects of wisdom, skillful, her wise intention, and skillful, her wise view. There are three aspects of meditation related to mindfulness, concentration, and skillful effort to practice. And then there are three aspects of ethical practice related to wise speech, to following the ethical precepts, and to what's called wise or skillful livelihood, is part of that as well. And so we want to remember it. Wisdom is partly about the teachings, but maybe more specifically it's about how can I have discernment in the present moment about what's appropriate for me to do, what's an appropriate response in the moment that requires discernment. That's part of wisdom as well. Now we have meditation. Again, I mentioned developing stability of mind, samadhi, concentration, developing mindfulness. I wish that the heart practices like loving kindness and compassion and joy and equanimity were part of the eightfold path. My vote would be to have a ninefold path and put in the heart practices. Anyone agree with me on that? Okay, we'll send the Buddhist authorities, notice that the Wednesday gathering on October 28th had a close to a consensus. So we can work with that. But these are really, really crucial. And then ethical practice I think is particularly underdeveloped in Western Buddhism. Those of you who've heard my talks know that this is a major theme. That ethical practice is somewhat marginalized. And even, it's tricky because even the words ethics for some of us can be a little bit of a weird word. It means like following the rules or something like that. But this really about care and responsiveness, helping others in multiple ways. And as I've often mentioned, the Buddha and many succeeding Buddhists didn't just think of this as what I do personally, but they thought of it as having a social dimension. So the Buddha, 2600 years ago, said, do not kill, do not approve of others killing, do not cause others to kill. It wasn't just one's own behavior. Very much like Thich Nhat Hanh, 2,500 years later said, do not kill, do not let others kill, find all means to prevent war. That's the ethical practice, right? Not an easy practice, is it, in our times? But that would be the guidance to practice like that. And I've often mentioned 300 years after the Buddha came King Ashoka who became a Buddhist, was Emperor of India for about 40 years and brought in Buddhist ethical practice to guide the whole society. I would vote for him for president. But what he did, he abolished the death penalty in India about 2300 years ago, okay? He renounced all war, said, I will never be engaged in a war. Our nation will never be engaged in a war. He set up aid stations for the poor and the elderly. He set up aid stations also for non-human animals to help other animals. I wish he was alive to be a candidate now. Okay, so that's ethical practice. And so we can really remember that and really remember these three dimensions of practice and also the importance of community. Many of us remember, I think, the quotation the Buddha's assistant Ananda once said, you know, you know, Buddha I've been thinking. And the Buddha said, okay, what have you been thinking about Ananda? He said, I've been thinking that community, the sangha, is really important. It's at least 50% of our, of the spiritual life. And the Buddha said, saying that is not so Ananda, community is 100% of the spiritual life. It's a really, really crucial, crucial, especially in our times. And it's helpful also to remember what may be the core teaching of the Buddha. And here, Marie-Christine, we can go to the image of the Buddha. This was an image of the Buddha giving his first talk. And this was, I went to last Friday when I was in Washington. I went to the Asian Art Museum at the Smithsonian Institution and which was a wonderful, wonderful museum. I'll have another image from there, maybe two more. And this is the Buddha giving his first talk. Giving his first talk. And the first talk, as many of you know, was the talk on the Four Noble Truths, I believe. And that was the core of that talk is saying that the problem is reactivity. Dukha, the core meaning of dukha being reactivity, the grabbing hold of the pleasant and the pushing away of the unpleasant. And it's possible to come to an end to dukha, an end to reactivity. So a simple way to talk about our practice is working through the habitual, compulsive role of the unconscious reactivity and instead of reactivity, developing responsiveness. I've often mentioned that if you want to talk to your relatives about Buddha's practice, talk about it as overcoming sort of compulsive reactivity and developing responsiveness. A very simple way to talk about our practice. And so, I can let go of a slide and go to the next one. This is an image, this next one is an image of a yogini, a female practitioner. This is from the, about the 9th century in India. And it's remembering that our practice is doing both deep inner work and skillful response. I think that's a very helpful way to think about it. We both have a sense of what is our inner work that we keep doing, but then also skillful response. There was, I think we can let go of the slides now. Those were also from the Smithsonian, the Asian Art Museum. In one way this was understood historically. A wonderful story from China in the 10th century. There was a teacher named Yunman in Japan known as Umman. And one day a monk came to this teacher and said, what is the highest and most profound teaching of all the Buddhas and all the great teachers? They may have been waiting and you may be waiting for some great deep metaphysical teaching, looking into the way that all phenomena interpenetrate in a scintillating emptiness that opens up the awakened mind. How's that sound? The Buddha didn't say that. I'm sorry, not the Buddha, but Yunnan didn't say that. What is the great teaching of all the Buddhas and all the great teachers? The answer was appropriate response. Another way to talk about the core of a practice. And I think it's helpful to see that in any given experience, and you can think particularly of our difficult experiences, what does appropriate response mean? I think there's both an inner response and an outer response. That we can do with something that's come up, we can do inner work, I can be mindful, oh, I'm feeling irritation and feeling anger. And there's also an outer response, a skillful outer response. So maybe some examples. And I think this is again, I think partly what I'm suggesting is a simple way to think about the core of our practice. Combine inner practice without a response, moment by moment. So two examples, okay? One example might be I have a difficult conversation with someone. I had a difficult conversation with someone maybe half an hour ago. What's an appropriate response or what's one form of appropriate response? I can explore my experience with mindfulness. I can be mindful, notice, oh, irritation, oh, frustration, oh, a little bit judgmental. I can notice all those things with mindfulness. I do my inner work, and if I do that enough and maybe bring in some compassion practice as well. And if I do that to a certain point, I work through the reactivity. And so there can still be some irritation, but I've worked through the reactivity. And I may be in a place then to have an outer response. How am I to skillfully speak with the person I was talking to? Right? So again, the inner work and the outer response, really, really crucial. Another example might be I'm upset by what I hear in the news. Anyone ever had that experience recently? I'm upset by what I hear in the news. Can we approach it with both an inner response and an outer response? Well, the inner response might be similar to what it was with the person I had a difficult conversation with. I can be mindful of my thoughts and emotions. Again, I think most of us probably don't do this so much. I hear the news. I feel frustration or anger. Can I be mindful and hang out with it? Can I even sometimes do mindfulness practice while the news is on? Anyone do that sometimes? It's an advanced practice. Right? I have one friend who does that. He's more to the left or progressive. He does that with Fox News. He listens to it and does mindfulness practice at the same time. So we could do that or we could just after we've noticed something, we are not listening to the news anymore, but we do some inner work. What's going on? Let me be with whatever it is. The anger, the being judgmental, whatever the thoughts of doom or whatever it might be. Can I be with those? And then secondly, what would my skillful response be? My more outer response? Maybe I would talk with others. Maybe I would actually act in the situation. So I'm suggesting some very, you know, some of the core ways to look at our practice. Understand moving from reactivity to responsiveness. And then these two dimensions of inner work and outer response at the same time. And I really think that what's needed at our times, we could say, is deep practice and deep responsiveness. We could say deep inner practice and deep engagement outwardly. That's what's called for in our times, I think. I'm interested in both writing about that and supporting that with others. Much like I've done in past years, I've sometimes done training programs for people who are doing social service or social action, social policy work to combine their inner work with acting in the world. So let's move now, and I think this is what I'll cover for the rest of the talk, to compassion practice and equanimity, because I think these are very central to what I've just been mentioning. And very briefly, compassion in Buddhist tradition, Karuna, is understood as a kind of inner trembling that we feel in relation to pain, whether our own pain or the pain of others, pain or difficulty. It's a kind of quivering of the heart that's taken to be very natural. Another word, it's also one of the words for compassion, anukampa is a kind of trembling when there is pain that we take in. And so compassion is developing the capacity to open to what's difficult or painful. We, of course, developed this maybe initially in our mindfulness practice, just being with the shoulder that hurts a little bit. Not too much, but it's unpleasant. And hanging out with that for a period is actually developing compassion. We're developing the capacity to be with the unpleasant and go against the tendency that we most of us grew up with when there's something unpleasant, get rid of it. And hence all the kind of the mixed way that we use drugs so much in our society, in our societies, right, to get rid of the pain. Sometimes with negative after effects. I won't go into that so much, but we learn in our mindfulness to be able to be with what's painful and have some balance and equanimity, a very crucial part of our practice. There's a way that compassion has both a receptive and an active dimension. The receptive is tuning into the pain and the more active dimension is responding outwardly. So we may tune into the pain of another, as I mentioned this earlier, but then we may do compassion practice with the other or actually help the other. Same thing with what we experience in the world. And sometimes this is shown in the figure of Kwan Yin, the Bodhisattva of Compassion, the being dedicated to helping others. And particularly, I'll have an image of Kwan Yin in a little while, that we can actually bring compassion to, or maybe Christina, why don't we bring in the image of Kwan Yin? And Kwan Yin is from China, and it is the being connected to compassion, really beloved. And this is an image also from the Asian Art Museum. Here Kwan Yin has 11 heads. Would you like to have 11 heads? The story is that Kwan Yin, with the compassion, was so initially overwhelmed by the pain in the world that Kwan Yin's head split open. But one of the great Buddhas, Amitabha, said, we'll put you back together again, but we'll fix you up with 11 heads so you can really hold the pain of the world a little bit better. That's the story of Kwan Yin's 11 heads. And in other images of Kwan Yin, and this is, again, this is from China, from, what is it, I think, the 5th or 6th century. In other images of Kwan Yin, more in paintings, Kwan Yin is shown as having sometimes a thousand arms. And each of the arms has a hand. The hand has an eye, which is the receptive aspect, and then the hand itself, which is the active dimension. So there are those two dimensions to, and these are really the two dimensions of compassion. And so we can practice compassion, as I've talked about in mindfulness, being with what's painful in our own experience. We can do heart practices like we did earlier, developing compassion. We can act to help, we can visit someone who is not doing well, we can reach out to friends who are having some pain. That would be a form of compassion. This is from Thich Nhat Han, the great Vietnamese teacher. Do not avoid contact with suffering, or close your eyes before suffering. Do not lose awareness of the existence of suffering in the life of the world. Find ways to be with those who are suffering, including personal contact, images, and sound. By such means, awaken yourself and others to the reality of suffering in the world. So we can let go of the slide now. So how do we work, for example, with the pain of the world? I want to mention five ways, pretty simple ways. One of them is really important is to set limits or boundaries for how much you take in. We can be overwhelmed by taking in too much stuff. We know that the algorithms of a lot of websites encourage us to take in more. So be careful about taking in. I have a lot of people I work with who don't take in more information after a certain time each day, maybe 8 p.m. or something. I found setting limits on the amount that I go into the news can be really helpful. That's one way to work with the pain of the world. Secondly, do inner practices, like I've mentioned, find ways to actually bring in with mindfulness of your own sense of pain in relation. Maybe bringing in compassion as well. Do your own inner work. Maybe work with