Skip to content
omnism.si

Orthodox · Compare this tradition with another

Can We Walk Together When We Disagree? | 10@9 | 2026.10.27

Rabbi Michael Whitman · Rabbi Michael Whitman (ADATH Congregation, Montreal) - Mining The Riches Of The Parsha · 2026-10-27 · Montreal · Source

This text has not been analysed yet.

Show the full text
Good morning. Today is Tuesday, October 27th, 2026. Alan and Debbie Jotkowitz made a lia in the 1990s. And what I want to share with you is partially based on an essay that Alan wrote. It was published in Lair House. They did their medical training in New Haven at Yale during the time that we lived in New Haven and we were very close and we remained close. And it is a privilege for me to share part of Alan's essay. He writes about himself that we were part of a blessed generation having grown up after the euphoria of the Six-Day War and the trauma of the Mkippur War. We were part of the first generation of American Jews to go en masse to Israel for a year or two of intense Torah study after high school. You may remember that really started in earnest in the 1990s. We fell in love with the country and its people. Many of us found a calling and purpose in life to eventually return to Israel and build our lives there, which Alan and Debbie did. It was an innocent time before the constant bombardment of social media and the Internet. And many of us heeded the ancient call of God to Avram from last week's Torah portion, Laak Lecha, and we made aliyah. And many of us joyfully celebrate our aliyah day as one does a birthday or a wedding anniversary. Our aliyah experience was not particularly difficult, especially when you compare our experience with the pioneers of the 1950s, 1970s, even more so earlier in the 20th century and the 19th century. We didn't have to wait years for a phone or a car and we built beautiful communities in Fratranana Bechemesh. Now he wrote this essay in November 2023, the experiences of the last three weeks he's writing since October 7th. Relate more closely to the second Laak Lecha command in the narrative of Avram. And that's the Laak Lecha and our Torah portion. Va yomer God said to Avram, kachna es bincha es yitchidcha asher ahavta es yitzchak, take your son, your only son, the son that you love, yitzchak, the Lech Lecha and go, el eretz Maria to the land of Maria, the hallaiyushan, the Olah, and offer him there as an offering. God tells Avram to sacrifice his beloved son, Yitzchak. Alan writes in the past few weeks, this ancient story of sacrifice, devotion and ultimately salvation has become too real for many of us living in Israel. As we have sent our sons and daughters off to battle. Some of us have reacted with Avraham's stoicism and continued to react by simply following God's decree without questions. But more of us have reacted with Sarah's tears. Alan then presents the approach to the difficulties in this narrative from Rabbi Shimon Gershen Rosenberg, a great Israeli scholar known as Rav Shagar. He passed away in 2007 and he presents a very distinct perspective on the troublesome, the troubling narrative of the Akheda, the binding of Isaac. He wrote this in an essay called Uncertainty as the Trial of the Akheda. And for Rav Shagar, the conflict was at the basis of this dilemma. Number one, the religious imperative forbidding murder and child sacrifice. And number two, God's commandment to offer Yitzchak as an offering. As an offering. And the most fundamental difficulty with that is the uncertainty of the nature of this trial. Rav Shagar suggests that Avraham was tested not just about his willingness to obey God's commandment, but perhaps was being tested about his willingness to disobey God's commandment. Perhaps God was commanding Avraham to do something, hoping that Avraham would say, no, what if the voice that Avraham heard from God was really a voice intending to deceive Avraham? That that's not what God wanted Avraham to choose. And even if it was truly God's voice demanding this offering, what God said itself was open to multiple interpretations. Avraham has no way of determining whether God truly wants him to sacrifice his son or whether his commandment is a ploy from Avraham's perspective. The primary challenge of the Akheda was that it was impossible for him to know what God really wanted him to do. And in so many ways, we too face uncertainty today. What does God want from us? The uncertainty in our lives reflects the uncertainty at the heart of this difficult narrative of the Akheda. Alan writes, in this interpretation, our current situation, again, November 2023, is very different from the Akheda. There is no ambiguity in our current situation. Because the Akheda is correctly named Akheda's Yitzchak, the binding of Isaac, not Akheda's Avraham or Sura, the Akheda or the test of Avraham and Sura. For all the tears and anguish Avraham and Sura must have gone through. It was Yitzchak who willingly put his life on the line. Likewise, it is our children, Alan writes, who are putting their lives on the line to protect the state of Israel. And then Alan presents another approach. The approach of Rav Yehuda Amital, which has an even more clear cut relevance to our situation today. Rav Amital writes that on the surface, if we look just on the surface of the text of the Torah, it would appear that Avraham accepts God's decree with silent submission. He's commanded to offer his son. And nothing can stand in the way of God's command. And so therefore Avraham nullifies his own will before the will of God. It would appear that Avraham suspends any human feelings of love, mercy, moral considerations. Everything stops. Everything freezes and disappears before God's command. Rav Amital writes, I think this interpretation is entirely mistaken. And then Rav Amital brings proof to his approach. For my rabbis in the mission, which teach that on public fast days, we are to add an extra blessing, an extra brocha to the Amida to the prayer that we say. And in fact, this line, we add to our prayers during the high holidays. And the prayer goes as follows. It's familiar to us. Misha Annalavramavina Baharamaria to the God who answered the prayer of Avraham at Har Maria, where the Akheda took place, who is the one who answered who? That God should answer me too. Just as God prayed that he would not have to offer his son. And God and Avraham was answered in his prayer. So too we beseech God today that God should listen to our prayer similarly and grant our prayer similarly, whatever that prayer may be. What we see from this line in the mission and from the prayer that we all say is that Avraham prayed fervently. This was Avraham's response. Yes, you commanded it to do. Yes, yes, God, you commanded me to do this, but I will pray with all of my heart, with all of my intensity for you not to have me go through with this. Our rabbis in the midrists describe this prayer in detail. Avraham placed his son on the altar. Avraham's eyes gazed on Yitzchak and Yitzchak's eyes gazed at the heavens. Tears welled and fell from Avraham's eyes until the pool of tears was as tall as he was. He said to him, my son, since you have already expressed your readiness to relinquish your blood, your Creator will find a different sacrifice in your place at that moment. Avraham's mouth opened with a great weeping and he sighed a great sigh and his eyes wandered seeking out God's presence. He lifted his voice and he said, Essa ain I al-Huram, I lift up my eyes to the mountains. May I in Yavvoh asri, where will my help come? Asri mayim ha-shem, O sehshimaim v'arit, my help will come from God, Creator of heaven and earth. Not for a moment was Avraham submissive. Not for a moment did Avraham set aside his feelings of mercy and fatherly love and morality. He engaged with all of his strength in what he had to do to respond to God's awesome command. And that was prayer. Avraham's love for his son neither disappeared nor dissipated. On the contrary of Amital rights, its intensity was a necessary condition for the Akheda itself. The essence of the Akheda lies precisely in that special loving relationship between father and son because it is the prayer of Avraham that leads to the outcome that Yitzchak has saved. The essence of the Akheda for us is expressed in prayer and what prayer can accomplish. So Allen writes, applying this today, and remember he's writing as his son and daughter and the sons and daughters of his friends and so many are going to battle willingly to protect the state of Israel, the people of Israel, and continue to do so to this day. Allen writes, what can we do as parents to follow the footsteps of our great ancestor, Avraham? We have to pray and we have to pray for the same answer given to Avraham at the Akheda when finally the angel said, do not stretch forth your hand, do not do the slightest thing to him. Gia'ni Adati, because I know God says that you are a person who reveres and respects God and another offering will be brought in his stead. We too, every one of us pray for the safety and the safe return of every one of our young people, our young men and women, who put themselves in harm's way and sometimes tragically do give their lives or their health. But we pray that they return safely. But Allen adds one more point, the Ram Ba' Maimonides teaches us that in a time of crisis, prayer alone is not enough. We also require tshuva repentance. And Allen makes the following observation. Three times in the Akheda story, we read, and they walked both of them together, unified, Avraham Yitzchak went together, unified in purpose. We're willing to sacrifice together, unified in purpose, and return together, unified, yachta. Togetherness seems to be a vital condition for the salvation of the Akheda. And Allen writes, and he was writing this three years ago, are we together today as a Jewish people? And I'll ask the question today, October 27, 2026. Are we together today as a people? As we speak, Israelis are voting in what many are calling the most fateful and consequential decision in Israel's history. Just a few minutes ago, I saw on the news that so far the turnout is higher than any election in the last 55 years. Politically, Israel is almost evenly divided. Of course, I'm not an Israeli citizen yet. I don't have, and I should not have, a vote. And I have no interest in sharing my choice. But I will and must say this. There is no contradiction between a divided electorate and Vayel Hushnehem Yachtav, and they went, both of them, together, united. As long as the outcome of this election is a shift by everyone to work together with each other, with respect for each other, not fear and not hatred, even as we disagree. The electorate can be divided. That's not the impediment. There must still be a way. Israel's leaders must still find a way, Vayel Hushnehem Yachtav. Not to agree, but to work together. This has been tragically lacking. But that's the side that I hope wins today. The side, the team, the government, the coalition that will work to heal the rifts in Israeli society. Not necessarily solve all of them, but at least to heal them. Because that was critical for the outcome Avraham prayed for and received. And that is absolutely critical for the outcome we pray for and we hope to receive. The outcome that I hope for is this. O Seh Shalom Bimramav, God, you make peace in heaven. Hu Yaseh Shalom Olayne. Please, please God, make peace for us. And I'll call you Israel for the entire Jewish people. Let us choose leaders that will be the vehicles, the instruments of God bringing peace to the people of Israel, to the entire Jewish people. My friends, I wish you a great day and I look forward to seeing you soon in person.