Joseph Goldstein: Q and A
This text has not been analysed yet.
Show the full text
Welcome everyone. Joseph Goldstein back with us. And I'll be asking him some questions. But I wanted to thank you for your questions. There were lots of, lots being really an important word here. Lots of great questions. What you might have noticed, if you were near the end, the bowl was heaped pretty high. So we condensed them into some larger sort of categories and kind of, you know, collated them into some broader categories that we can then have Joseph respond. This first one is kind of in two parts and we'll see. I can repeat the second one if it drifts away, which it would for me. But it's really simple. What is insight? Insight, of insight meditation is the usual translation of the Pali word vipassana. And the literal meaning of vipassana is to see things clearly. And so you could say that we're all practicing seeing clearly meditation. And so then the question is, what do we see when we're seeing clearly in the context of the Buddhist teachings? And I think it's good to frame that. What is the insight that serves the aspiration of enlightenment, of freedom? Because that is the purpose, the deepest purpose of all these teachings. The simplest way of understanding the kind of insights that lead to that are insights into the three characteristics of impermanence, dukkha, and non-selflessness. Because each of them in different ways diminish and in the end eradicate the force of craving and clinging. And the Buddha laid this out very clearly in the Four Noble Truths, the truth of dukkha, and then the cause of it, which is craving, and the end of it could be understood as the realization of nibbana, which is the end of craving, the end of clinging. So it's pretty straightforward, and I think as mentioned in one of the earlier talks, a comment of my first teacher, it's simple, it's not complicated. It's simple but not easy, as you well know. But I think that's what the insight is fundamentally about, insight into the three characteristics as an expression of the Four Noble Truths. Did I pass? This is a fail pass kind of a... Before we continue, I think the hearing, is your hearing assisting working? Is that working now? Does anyone know if there are any more of the hearing assisted devices? Maybe the battery's gone out, I'm really sorry. Would it help to come closer? There's a chair right up here next to Ray. Sorry about that. So there's a second part of this question. Sometimes this is felt and seen and even described as the dry path of insight. How would we moisten or soften that dryness? Some tips for that. First, what it refers to is, for those of you who are familiar with the sutas, you know that in very many discourses, the Buddha talks about the development of jhana. You know, the deep states of concentration and absorption. And using that then as the basis for insight, for investigation. But in the sutas, there is also what is called the path of dry insight, which means developing insight without jhana. And the kind of concentration that's developed in this path of dry insight is called momentary concentration, which means the mind's concentrated and can get quite concentrated, but in a moment to moment way, where it's seeing the impermanence all along the way. In jhana practice, that leads to an absorption. And in that practice, in that kind of concentration, one is not actually seeing impermanence. Because the whole path of that kind of concentration is one pointedness on a single object and then becoming absorbed in that concentration, in that one pointedness. For those people who have a facility for concentration, who have kind of a natural ability for it, the development of jhana can be really helpful. It's a very powerful foundation of samadhi to develop deepening insight. So it was likened to, if you want to cross like a big lake, if one has the foundation of jhana level concentration, it's like having a motorboat. So you can get across the lake quite quickly and quite easily. And dry insight would be like swimming across the lake. In both cases, one gets across the lake. But the interesting thing to consider is that for some people and perhaps even for many people, it takes longer to build the boat than to swim across the lake. So one just has to really see where one's meditative talents lie. So for some people, the investigation factor is very strong. And if that's very predominant, it can actually be a hindrance to the development of jhana because one is always investigating the impermanence and the non-self. And that is not helpful for that level of absorption, where you don't want to be investigating that. You want to just be sinking into the object. So for people with that very investigative mind, it may be... Me, so I'm very familiar with this. It may be that the development of jhana is actually not the quickest path. And yet for other people, they have that facility. So it really depends just on our own particular power, needs, backgrounds, what qualities of mind are very predominant. Both paths get to the same place. I think dry inside, it's an unfortunate term. Maybe come up with a better one. I guess I could follow it just a little bit. If one is experiencing the practice of having a kind of dryness, is there something that you found useful to soften or add a moisture content? Certainly, it's something you've been practicing, certainly with the Brahma Viharas, whether it's metto or compassion. I don't know if there's been much teaching on mudita, the empathetic joy, because of the four, often that's the one that gets ignored a little bit. In terms of what's taught and practiced. But any one of those four will bring that moisture. At some point, for those of you who were interested, I found that practicing the mudita, it was like eating ice cream. It's delicious. What's striking is, it may be the hardest of the ones, or the one we least practiced in, of really cultivating that delight in the happiness of others. When we undertake it as a formal practice and cultivate it, it's a totally beautiful quality of mind and it's very uplifting. Would you please tell us a little bit more about your understanding of emptiness? What is emptiness? In classical Theravada teachings, it really means empty of self. So it's pretty straightforward. It's the whole teaching of non-self. Non-self is just fundamental to this whole practice and to the Buddha's realization. And there are so many places in the suttas where the Buddha refers to this. One of the common refrains is the line where the Buddha says, Everything should be seen with perfect wisdom. This is not mine. I am not. This is not my self. And so he's applying that to every arising phenomena. And just that phrase, that could be a very interesting recollection, almost like a vipassana mantra, especially as you're meditating and in your experience, either when you feel like you're getting caught by something or even when things are just flowing smoothly, just to drop that phrase in, but particularly with kind of sticky thoughts or emotions, where we're getting caught, to remind oneself, this is not mine. The translation from the Pali is this I am not. This is a little awkward English. So we could say this is not mine, not I, not myself, but a reminder to not be identified with whatever it is that's arising. There's one other way of expressing that in terms of thoughts and emotions. One could say the thought is the thinker. It's not that there's someone behind it who's having it. The thought is thinking itself. With different emotions, we could say love loves and anger angers and fear fears. It's like each emotion is arising out of conditions, expressing its own nature and passes away, but it doesn't belong to anybody. However, our conditioning, very deep condition, is that we appropriate everything. We appropriate things as being I and mine. And so our practice, and this goes back to the first question about insight, a transformative insight is the slow realization that there is no one behind experience to whom it's happening. Each experience is simply manifesting its own nature. And then it gets interesting to see which experiences do you most habituated to identify with. Are there certain patterns of thought? Are there certain emotions that always grab us? So when you see that, then it would be useful to just remind yourself. Not mine, not I, not myself. And it's very liberating, it's very freeing. So one little trick you can use in your sitting when you're caught up in a lot of thought, just imagine that all the thoughts that are arising in your mind are coming from the person next to you. They're just kind of coming through. It might help you dis-identify a little bit, blame it on them. What is the mind? It's actually not such a difficult question. Thankfully the Buddha figured all this out. I mean if we had kind of figured this out ourselves, we'd be in trouble. But the Buddha laid it out very clearly and for those of you of a certain bent of mind, the Abhidharma, which is often called the Buddhist psychology, is just such a clear analysis basically of that question. What is the mind? And I think I talked about it in the first or second talk. Fundamentally the mind, we could identify it as consciousness, which is the capacity to know. It's that faculty which cognizes things. And what does it cognize? It cognizes the sixth sense objects, mind as a sixth sense, so thoughts and emotions. So consciousness is that which knows the object. And then as I think I mentioned in one of the talks, it also arises with a lot of mental factors, those qualities which color consciousness, wholesome, unwholesome, leading to suffering, leading to more happiness. So mindfulness, concentration, love, fear, anger, grief, all these are mental factors, also impersonal, arising and passing. So that is the fundamental understanding of what the mind is, consciousness plus mental factors. Now this is not highlighted so much in the Theravada teachings and more in Zen and Tibetan teachings, but I found it really helpful as a way of understanding the empty nature of the mind. So there's a little Zen story which encapsulates this particular teaching. So Bodhidharma was this classical figure who brought Buddhism from India to China. So he went to China and he was just sitting in a cave for so many years and then slowly people went to see him and get teachings. So at a certain point this one man who became his chief disciple or one of his early disciples, he came really distressed, his mind was in torment. And so he came to Bodhidharma and he said, please teach me how I can come out of this suffering, please pacify my mind. And as the Zen story goes, Bodhidharma said to him, well show me your mind and I'll pacify it. And this man his name is Huayka said, I've looked for it everywhere and I can't find it. And Bodhidharma said, there it's already pacified. And so there's a really powerful teaching in that. In that when we look for the mind, even as we understand how it's functioning, that it's the cognizing power colored by all the mental factors, yet when we look for it, there's nothing to find because it's not a thing, it's not a material thing, we can't find it and yet the knowing is happening. And so I think that glimpsing that non-findability, even as the knowing is happening, is a very interesting discovery and it really helps to free the mind from any clinging to it. Or even from any identification with it. As I mentioned last week, I think the last holdout of self is that identification with knowing, with awareness. But when you look for it and there's nothing to find, that's one way of cutting through that identification. So it's a little experiment, if you like, and it's something I've just found really interesting to do. Sometimes when I'm sitting, and if there happen to be a lot of sounds, external sounds happening, so sometimes I'll be aware of hearing, be mindful of hearing, mindful of the sound, and then I'll ask myself while I'm sitting, well can I find what's knowing the sound? And so that question is just a way of turning the mind back to look to see, okay, is there something that I can find that is knowing the sound? And when one looks, there's nothing to find, and yet the knowing is still happening. So to me, this is the great mystery of consciousness, that it can't be found and yet it's manifesting its function. So if you like, you can play with it a little bit. In some traditions, I think in the Thai forest particularly, they speak about the original mind or that which knows as another way of expressing the sense of primal mind. Sometimes Ajahn Man would say the primal mind. Do you have a sense for how that fits with what you just said? Okay, here's where it gets complicated. Thank you. Sorry. So in classical Theravada teachings, consciousness itself or awareness itself is one more conditioned, impermanent experience. And there are times in Vipassana practice, certain stages of insight where one is actually experiencing the rapid flow of consciousness itself, seeing that consciousness itself is arising and passing. And so in these classical teachings, consciousness, awareness, is still within the realm of conditioned phenomena. It arises out of conditions. In some of the later schools of Buddhism, they posit an unconditioned awareness. So in that way of understanding, awareness, you could say, awareness becomes the ground in which everything is happening, but the awareness itself is seen as unconditioned. That is not how it's understood in early Buddhism. So it's just to be clear about that distinction. What's interesting about the Thai forest tradition is that there's not a uniform view on that question. Some teachers tend to, the later schools of Buddhism, awareness as being the ground, and other Thai forest masters say, yes, this is also not to be clung to. This also is not permanent. So the Thai forest tradition actually has both strands to it. Independent of these ultimate, different takes on the ultimate view, independent of which one experiences or ascribes to, the realization in both comes through not clinging. Nothing whatsoever is to be clung to as I or mine. So if you land on that, then everything else will take care of itself. And that's why I always come back to, what are we practicing? And when people ask me, because I practice with different teachers and different traditions, and so often they'll ask, well, what are you practicing? And I always, I'm practicing not clinging to anything as being I or mine. And that just gets to the heart of it. And then maybe when we're fully enlightened, we'll have the answer to these metaphysical questions. So it just feels like a very, an understanding common to all traditions, that non-clinging is the essence of freedom. So that's really simple. It's straightforward. And it cuts across all the different traditions and interpretations. Is enlightenment possible for laypeople? Yes. Go for it. So as you probably know, and I've heard, again, within the Tervata system, there are four stages of enlightenment. Stream entry, which is the first glimpse of Nibbana. Once returner, which is where desire and aversion are reduced, but not eliminated. Third stage of enlightenment called non-returner, Anagami. Desire and aversion are completely uprooted from the mind stream. And then Ahamchip, which is full enlightenment. So for example, our teacher Deepa Ma was a laywoman. You know, a family, householder. She was an extraordinary woman, but she had reached that third stage of enlightenment, which is, I mean, can you imagine a mind completely free of sense, desire, and aversion? I mean, that's quite a state. Even an Ahamchip, full enlightenment, said it's possible, although in this particular tradition, it says that if one becomes an Ahamchip as a layperson, and I'm not sure, this may be commentarial. It says, if you happen to become an Ahamchip as a layperson, you have seven days to take the robes or you leave this life. It said the lay life cannot sustain the Ahamchip. For most of us, this is not a big concern. And again, I think this is part of the commentary, so who knows. But the first stages, and particularly the first two, that's definitely possible for laypeople. Again, it's not easy, but it's not outside the realm of possibilities. And there are many Westerners who have realized that. The third stage, that's a leap. That's a significant jump from the second. But still, as Deepama showed, it can be done if the Parmes are there. So I want to just mention something else. There are two, could call states or stages, that the Buddha highlighted prior to stream entry. And he called them faith follower and Dhamma follower. And he made some really interesting statement about these levels of understanding. And the faith follower is somebody who has heard the teachings and just out of this very strong faith in the Buddha and in the teachings has really come to a full acceptance of them. And then the Dhamma follower is one where investigation is the primary strength of mind. And so they've investigated the teachings, not only like complete faith in them, but investigated them and really come to understand, for example, the three characteristics. So these states, I think, are quite common among our sanghas, you know, of people who are really devoted to practice. These are very available and I think even quite common. And the Buddha talked about it. He said, these are noble individuals. They're no longer ordinary worldlings. And this is right from the suttas. This isn't at discourses. They are almost certainly assured of enlightenment if they keep practicing. So I'd like to talk about that because sometimes we create a... We can become so fixated on, for example, stream entry or highest stages and then get the scourge or we've been practicing so many years and haven't quite tasted that yet. But they're missing the actual level of experience that we've had in practice that the Buddha highlighted as being transformative and really has put us on the path and, as I say, become noble individuals no longer ordinary worldlings as the expression goes. So I think it's really important to understand that for many and probably most of you, you know, really devoted themselves to practice and long intensive practice, this is not uncommon at all. But we just have that a really good understanding of the teachings. Since you mentioned Deepama, is there a story that you might be able to share about your... She seems to have been an extraordinary being and I know you practiced and spent time with her. Is there something you could share from that time? So she was extraordinary and she just combined incredible powers of concentration. She mastered all the jhanas and psychic powers and just all of that and had attained these high level stages of enlightenment. So she could go into a state of samadhi for days at a time. She would sit down and then three or four days later she'd get up. So one time I was in Bulgaria, she was visiting Bulgaria from Calcutta and we were walking and she turned to me and she said, I think you should sit for a weekend or sit for two days, something like that. And she didn't mean a weekend retreat. She meant sit down and get up two or three days later. That was exactly my reaction. I started to laugh. And she turned to me and she said, don't be lazy. I don't think...it's only laziness. There's something else that's limiting this. But it was so beautiful. I mean she just...she held out the possibility of the highest aspirations and she just did it with just this incredible love. So in some way she was the teacher who was most inspiring to me. Just somebody once asked her what was in her mind and she said peace, concentration and love. That's all that was in there. Pretty good. So she just radiated this loving kindness. And beautiful. And I think the fact that she was a lay woman with a family leading the household life, that's