Skip to content
omnism.si

Theravada · Compare this tradition with another

Bernat Font: Suggestions for Deepening Practice; Vedanas

Bernat Font · Gaia House (Devon) - Dharma Talks · 2026-09-24 · Newton Abbot · Source

This text has not been analysed yet.

Show the full text
Okay, so this morning I wanted to introduce a few more suggestions to deepen practice, but feel free to take them or leave them. Maybe what we've offered is enough for you and you can just keep practicing in the same way today. The river alluded to the Satipatthana Sutta, the discourse on the cultivation of mindfulness or the foundations or establishments of mindfulness. And the first of these is mostly what we do as anchors, mindfulness of the body, becoming aware of the body and that includes being aware of the posture, being aware of the breath, etc. Of course, as we do that, we also become aware of other things that happen while we try to feel the breath or feel the contact with the ground, like thoughts or moods, sensations, etc. And the second cultivation of mindfulness, the second place where we direct our awareness that we are aware in relation to is pleasure and pain. And there's a collective name for this in Buddhist terminology, it's called Vedana. And it basically refers to the fact that anything that we experience falls somewhere in a spectrum from pleasant to painful and anything in between. We might say comfortable or nice or unpleasant or unbearable or painful. But it's all in that spectrum, so anything we feel at all, whether that's body sensations or sensory input including moods and emotions and thoughts, all that feels good or it feels bad or kind of neither, some things are just neutral. Neither, you would not call them pleasant, you would not call them unpleasant, just somewhere in the middle. So thoughts, for example, it's like, oh, maybe having this fantasy, that feels quite nice. Or that memory that's unpleasant, a certain emotion, certain mood might feel good, quite nice, might feel uncomfortable. A sound you hear might make you feel good or bad, certainly body sensations. So there's this aspect of things, their pleasantness, their unpleasantness or the neutralness. That seems pretty obvious and perhaps pretty insignificant. So why would Buddhism dedicate one of the main cultivations of mindfulness to becoming aware of this? And the reason is equally obvious, because of this, is what governs our behavior. This is what governs our attention. I don't want a piece of cake because of the piece of cake, but because of the pleasant feeling, I think it will give me. I don't want to get rid of some painful body sensation, because it's a body sensation, but because it's painful. So this is the specific thing that governs our clinging and our wanting and our rejecting and our ignoring and not paying attention. So when something's neutral, it's like it's nothing to me. I don't need to pay attention to this. How could it be relevant? So it's really central to our behavior and sometimes we can build a lives just based on this fiction, that we can amass everything that makes us feel good and keep it there, while at the same time pushing away and keeping out of our experience everything that makes us feel bad. And unfortunately, it doesn't work like that, because we're not the only ones playing this game and other people have different ideas. And also, these things don't last very much. The third slice of cake is still a slice of cake, it's probably not that pleasant. So today I want to suggest also widening our practice to also become aware of this. And you don't need to make a big project of it, you can if you want to, but it's not necessary. But to investigate a little bit, what's our relationship to pleasant when something feels nice? What happens then? When something feels bad? What do we do? What does the mind do? How does our relationship to that also change the thing? How does, for example, our resistance to pain increase the pain? And perhaps to then cultivate different relationships to these things. So to give a few examples, let's take the pleasant. So it's not just as simple as sometimes we may hear that if it's pleasant I want more of it, if it's unpleasant I want to push it away. Sure, that's true a lot of the time. It's a bit more complex. So with the pleasant on kind of one side of the one extreme we might have the usual, well, if it's nice or I want more, I expect it to last. I hope it stays. I expect it to stay. I expect it to happen again and make me feel the same way. I want to extend it. I want to intensify it. We cling to it. And perhaps part of that starts to be, or without this, then I feel diminished. I feel lesser. I need that. I don't only want that. If this goes away, then something is suddenly challenged. I feel lacking. On the other kind of extreme we can have sort of the opposite reaction. We might have an excessive fear of clinging to anything pleasant to the point that when we're in a nice state we try to make it stop. This feels too good. This is tonight. No, I don't trust it. Enough. We're so afraid that we're going to cling to it and we don't even let ourselves experience it. And we push it away. And if we do experience it, perhaps we feel guilty or suspicious of what's going to happen next. With the painful, again on one extreme we might have the stoic stereotype, just put up with it. That's what being strong means, tough. And making any adjustment that's for weak people. And on that logic, if I end up making any adjustment, let's say, to ease some of the discomfort of the body in the posture, then I feel like I failed. I could not bear that. I could not practice with it. I had to make an adjustment. I should have been able to just put up with it. So this is fine with second rate practice. On the other kind of extreme we have that attitude that at the minimum sign of adversity I surrender. At the minimum side of adversity, I think I cannot handle it. I could not possibly handle this. This is bigger than me. I make an adjustment straight away. I change. I avoid any discomfort. Any moment of the same reason we reach for our phones when we're slightly bored for a few seconds. And again, on that logic also we put that into the language of being kind to myself, which protects it from being questioned. And once it becomes a synonym of being kind to myself, then I really start experiencing myself as completely unable to experience any kind of discomfort. And trying to do that is suddenly being very mean or cruel to myself. I think it's going to the other extreme of the stoic stereotype. So you can see where you might fall on the spectrum between these two poles at any given time with both the pleasant or the unpleasant. And you just need to observe that. It's very useful information. And trust that you can be aware of that. You can be aware of that. There's something called the Seven Factors of Awakening. I won't go into the whole thing now. But the third and the fourth are courage and joy. And they're kind of both about our ability to be with discomfort, that's courage, and our ability to be with pleasure and joy. That's joy. And both can be tremendously empowering. Tremendously empowering. We might discover that we can be uncomfortable for a bit. And maybe we'll make an adjustment and we'll do something else a little later. But maybe we can be with discomfort for a little longer than we believed. And in that comes a lot of confidence and belief in oneself, which is probably the kindest thing we can ever do for ourselves. We may discover that we can feel nice for a while without suspecting that something must be wrong or I might be deluded. If I'm feeling okay, maybe I'm missing out on something. And allowing ourselves to experience being okay for longer than we're kind of comfortable with it in a way can be quite interesting. I mean, I still remember a while on long retreat here. And on long retreats, sometimes you might kind of touch some depth of meditation. And I remember getting into a state that was very pleasant and very nice. And I remember seeing very clearly my mind going, okay, it's been 20 seconds, stop. No. And I pulled out from it. And then later, that became quite an interesting reflection like, what's that? What's that mechanism? And I mean, it's not necessarily a bad thing. It's something unfamiliar and quite out of the ordinary and strange. You know, why would you trust it at first sight? You know, so a little deep and then maybe tomorrow we'll revisit this. But just to see these reactions without needing to make up a story in the moment about what this means about me. But to see it clearly, oh, I pull out from this. Oh, I go straight into it. Oh, I cling. Oh, I reject it. You know, so again with discomfort or pain. So this Vedana, this tonality of experience as pleasant unpleasant, neither, we can use this today just to deepen a little bit more to kind of investigate, inquire into our relationship to it. Or you can use this quite simply as a way to be more fully in the experience. Sometimes you feel the breeze while doing walking meditation and just taking a moment to kind of savor. Oh, that's a little pleasant. That draws you closer to it. It enhances your mindfulness. An important caveat perhaps with this is to not transform this into an exercise in kind of feeling a spreadsheet with, you know, this is pleasant, this is unpleasant, this is neutral. I'm not sure about this. How do I feel about this? Is it pleasant? Is it unpleasant? Is it like once you're doing this, you're just thinking. Also, it probably means it's neutral. You know, that's the undecided bit. Also to clarify that I'm just speaking about how things feel. I'm not saying that something is good or something is bad. It's just like how it feels. It feels good. It feels pleasant. It feels unpleasant. So no, it's not a kind of moral assessment of whether things are right or wrong. It's just becoming aware of how it feels on that spectrum. Okay, so we'll do a little bit of sitting and in that sitting, I'll make a few suggestions in relationship to this. So first, just settling as usual, continuing our practice. Maybe there's quite some momentum already today. Maybe this morning the mind is agitated or sluggish. We can hold that spaciously and rest in our main anchor. We can scan the body and maybe we find an area that's on the unpleasant side, hopefully not too intense. Maybe just some slight discomfort and we can just know unpleasant. Something we can practice with, especially bodily discomfort, but that's... We can extend that to even emotional pain. Is to see how the tendency of our mind is to go right to the pain and become sucked into it and restrict the field of awareness to the sore spot. And so we can practice the opposite, having a large awareness. Perhaps the whole body, but at least bigger than the sore spot, so that we're not pushing away this experience. But we're including it in a hole that includes other things. We bring more space around it and we can continue to be aware of this discomfort in the body without centering it. It's there, but in the margins. To one side. Our awareness is wider. Awareness may keep trying to shrink to that spot. We keep enlargening it. And sometimes it also helps if instead of simply having a larger awareness with that discomfort to one side, we choose something that's not uncomfortable at the center of that awareness. Maybe the breath, maybe another part of the body that feels neutral or even slightly pleasant. Again, you can find in the body areas without discomfort, areas perhaps that feel nice, pleasant, simply okay. We can use them to rest our awareness, making use of the fact that generally we like what feels good. So if we find some comfort, coziness, pleasure, then it's easier for the mind to settle there. We don't need to change the sensation. We don't need to intensify it. But we may become aware of wishes along those lines. Clinging. Can we just be with it expansively in a sort of sunbathing attitude that doesn't hold on? Where did your mind last go? Did it go to a pleasant place? An unpleasant place? Or a neutral place? What was the tonality of the last train of thought you followed? Just recognize and continue with your anchor. Sometimes we feel complex things and it can be helpful and easier to relate to the simple, label unpleasant than with the whole complexity of a story. So a few more thoughts or suggestions for this. If you were doing walking meditation outside and you're trying to catch Vedana like catching butterflies, it's going to be a pretty scattered walking. But one thing that you can do while you're on your walking path is choose a sensory channel. Choose touch or even more specific like the soles of your feet or choose sound or choose smell or sight. Choose one channel and then you can approach that particularly through the lens of pleasant unpleasant neither. Not trying to follow any particular sensation of pleasure or pain but sort of in that channel you can see the dynamic choreography of pleasant unpleasant neither. It keeps changing. You can feel how the sensations of the soles of your feet as you walk are this mosaic, moving mosaic of now little pleasant unpleasant. Just as a way to kind of be into it. Same with sounds. That is one way. It's also interesting to reflect on how these tonalities, they're not an intrinsic property of the object. Otherwise everyone would like the same foods. It's not something we can choose in the moment. It's just how a certain thing appears to us in that moment and it might have lots of reasons. Some of them evolutionary and quite universal. It's kind of hard to not like sugar for example. But also they are personal from our upbringing, our cultures. It's a big one in why some foods appear very weird and unpleasant to us and others don't. And also the environment and even the mood of the moment so that the same thing might feel different at different times because of the setup in our mind, our underlying mood. A lot of these also come from the meaning we give to things. The meaning we give to things. So if I tell you you're a wonderful group of meditators, that will probably feel nice. If I say it, let's say in Spanish, let's assume, I know some of you speak Spanish, but a lot of you will not speak Spanish. So it's a bad group of meditators. Then you know that might feel neutral just because I told you what it means. But if I reveal to you that in Spanish I have actually said that you're a horrible group of meditators, right? But you didn't know what some of you knew. But you didn't know. So clearly that pleasantness or unpleasantness or neither doesn't come from sound. It comes from how you process that sound in your mind and give it meanings that you've learned. So this can be quite an interesting area of practice and reflection. And it's not like you need to think in this way the whole time during the practice. But as a bit of context is interesting to really just take these tonalities as the way something feels to me in the moment. Because very often we go a step further. We assign that tonality to the thing itself and we believe therefore it must be good and worth pursuing. Or it must be horrible and worth rejecting. But that's just an emergence of the mind and body in the moment. You probably remember foods that you liked or that you didn't like as a kid and you like now. Or groups of music that you loved as a teenager and now you cringe when you're like, oh I listened to that. So these things change with time. They change with the moment. They are how your mind feels about that in the moment. And so in some sense becoming aware of this is to start to become more aware of the mind. That's a crucial difference between kind of a sense object or a physical object. And to start focusing on how does it feel. So we're starting to kind of change the arrow of our awareness towards ourselves and our own minds. And how it experiences things.