omnist.world

Deutsch

Climate movement · Compare this tradition with another

Indigenous Peoples have a message to miners: our Territories are not for sale

no name given · Greenpeace International · 2026-11-18 · Amsterdam · Source

Justice · main message Community · carrying

Die Energiewende darf nicht auf der Ausbeutung indigener Gebiete und der Verletzung ihrer Rechte basieren, da dies koloniale Gewaltstrukturen reproduziert und die Klimakrise verschärft.

Unsere Souveränität stammt aus unseren Völkern und unseren Gebieten: Sie kann nicht zwischen der Oberfläche und dem Untergrund geteilt werden, denn das Land, die Gewässer, die Mineralien und die dort aufrechterhaltenen Lebensweisen bilden ein einziges Gebiet des Lebens.

Der Text berichtet über ein Seminar der APIB und eine anschließende Erklärung indigener Völker in Brasilien, die sich gegen den Bergbau in ihren Gebieten aussprechen. Die Autoren argumentieren, dass die Nutzung kritischer Mineralien für die Energiewende oft als Vorwand dient, um indigene Rechte zu verletzen und Ökosysteme zu zerstören. Sie werfen Regierungen und Unternehmen vor, eine koloniale Logik der Ausbeutung zu reproduzieren, indem sie indigene Völker als Hindernisse für die wirtschaftliche Entwicklung betrachten. Die Kernforderung ist das Recht auf Selbstbestimmung und die freie, vorherige und informierte Zustimmung (FPIC), die ein echtes Vetorecht einschließen muss. Der Text kritisiert, dass Konsultationen oft nur zur Legitimation bereits getroffener Entscheidungen dienen. Es wird gefordert, dass eine gerechte Energiewende historische Ungleichheiten adressieren und die Rechte der Ökosystem-Schützer respektieren muss. Die Souveränität der indigenen Völker wird als untrennbar mit ihrem Land und ihren Lebensweisen verbunden dargestellt.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Exploitation, oppression, unequal conditions; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality
Where does the evil reside?
in the economy, politics, or social structures
What helps against it?
just social or political conditions; practical action towards the neighbour, good works
What is human being according to this text?
self-determined, the author of one's own actions
Where is history heading?
it is getting worse, an order is coming to an end
What does the text base its claim on?
on tradition, the fathers, an established practice; on personal experience, testimony, encounter
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
also to animals, plants, and all of creation
Where is the text's criticism directed?
at others, at society, at other groups

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Measured

Basic stance
-1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
2 of 3
Reach
4 of 5
Concreteness
2 of 3
Boundary
2 of 3, named: Regierungen und Unternehmen
Time
past 1, present 3, future 2

Analysed with qwen/qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
Indigenous territories have long been treated as frontiers open for exploitation, while its Peoples, who have protected the lands for generations, face fresh threats to their physical, cultural, spiritual, and territorial integrity. Earlier this month, the Articulation of Indigenous Peoples of Brazil (APIB) held a seminar “This Land Has an Owner: Indigenous Territories Free from Mining”, with the aim to discuss the threats posed by industrial and illegal mining to Indigenous territories, ways of life, and autonomy Following the gathering, Indigenous Peoples launched a statement that represents their stance against a movement that is gaining momentum with the global race for critical minerals and rare earth elements, weaponising the argument that these resources are necessary for the energy transition. Here’s what they had to say. Mining in the Sararé Indigenous Land, demarcated in 1985. © Fabio Bispo / Greenpeace When the energy transition relies on opening up new frontiers for exploitation, violating rights, and destroying ecosystems, it reproduces the colonial logic that has historically turned territories into sources of raw materials while leaving local populations to bear the socio-environmental costs of that exploitation. While governments and corporations present mining as an inevitable path towards sustainability, Indigenous Peoples warn this must not be used as a justification to deepen the violence, contamination, and appropriation of their territories. Illegal and industrial mining have been posing threats to Indigenous Lands, such as heavy metal contamination from mercury and lead, as well as the destruction of their sacred sites, provoking a series of negative impacts among the peoples and communities who have historically protected the forest and its ecosystems. From March 16 to 21, 2025, Greenpeace Brazil and Greenpeace Germany, together with partners, carried out an agenda in the state of Mato Grosso to denounce the occurrence of mining in the Amazon Indigenous Lands. © Samara Souza / Greenpeace Indigenous Peoples refuse to be treated as obstacles to economic development. Self-determination is a fundamental right: it is up to the Peoples themselves to decide on their life projects, their forms of organisation, and what may or may not take place on their Territories. For this reason, Indigenous Leaders reject consultations carried out merely to legitimise decisions already made by the state or by corporations. Consultation cannot be reduced to a box-ticking exercise to push projects through, but must serve as an instrument to uphold the right to decide. Free, prior, and informed consent must respect the autonomous protocols of each person and guarantee a genuine right of refusal. Greenpeace Brazil calls for confronting an extractivist model that disregards the social, environmental, cultural, and spiritual dimensions of Indigenous Territories. Projects that shape the future of their lands cannot move forward based on the logic of cobbled-together political majorities, continuing to inflict pain and suffering on Brazil’s more than 300 Indigenous nations. As Indigenous leaders state in their final letter at the end of the seminar: Our sovereignty stems from our peoples and our territories: it cannot be divided between the surface and the subsoil, because the land, the waters, the minerals, and the ways of life sustained there form a single territory of life Indigenous land affected by mining in Mato Grosso, Brazilian Amazon. © Samara Souza / Greenpeace A truly just energy transition must confront historical inequalities, reduce pressure to open new extractive frontiers, and respect the rights of those who protect the ecosystems vital to climate balance. There is no climate justice when the response to the environmental crisis reproduces the very forms of violence that helped create it. Read the full final letter (in Portuguese) here. Camila Garcez is a Campaign Engagement Analyst at Greenpeace Brazil. Defend the defenders Demand the recognition of Indigenous rights and their territories. Join now