The Holiness of the Struggle
This text has not been analysed yet.
Show the full text
Welcome to the Queer Theology podcast. I'm Brian G. Murphy and I'm Father Shannon T. Elkerns. We're the co-founders of QueerTheology.com and your hosts. From Genesis to Revelation, the Bible declares good news to LGBTQ plus people and we want to show you how. Tune in each week on Sunday for conversations about Christianity, queerness and transness and how they can enrich one another. We're glad you're here. Before we dive into this episode, we just wanted to remind you that our new book, Reading the Bible Through Queer Eyes, good news for LGBTQ plus people from Genesis to Revelation, is available for pre-order now. You can buy anywhere books are sold. We're super excited to share these quintessential stories from our decades of work, queering the Bible and making this work accessible to people. So the book is available for pre-order now. It comes out in December and we hope you'll grab a copy. Welcome back to the Queer Theology podcast. Today, we are talking about quick fixes in spirituality and religion and life. I've been thinking about this because I've been working as a chaplain for a while now. I often can only have very brief encounters with folks before I get interrupted by something else. One of the things that I'm struck by, and again, I'm in a very conservative state in a very conservative, evangelical, permeated space. And often people will come in to talk to me and kind of expect, I can see in their eyes that they are expecting me to fix the problem with a word. So I'm going to come in and be like, I've experienced all of this loss in my life. I don't know how to grieve. What do I do? And then they look at me and I'm like, well, grief is complicated. It takes a really long time. And I've just been struck by this desire, but even more than a desire. Because I think all of us desire, we wish that there was a magic want. When we are in pain and then suffering, whether that is physical, emotional, spiritual, whatever. I have a thought today. Yeah. I wish that I could fix it. And what I think evangelicalism often does is that they teach us that we can. Pray the right prayer, pray it in the right way, open your Bible and read the right Bible verse and you will be healed. Right? Like you will be instantly healed. We see that in the faith healing movement, you know, in the dramatic, I'm going to lay hands on you and kapow. But we also see it, I think, like in other ways of like, if you just prayed right. And I've also been thinking about this because I was at a conference the other week and again, very evangelical. And I noticed that the way that they were talking about ministry, it was very metric oriented, right? You're going to get X number of people to pray the prayer. And we're going to get X number of people to disciple someone else. And we're going to like, right? And it was very clear metrics and very clear numbers. And I sat there and I thought, Oh, like no wonder this appeals to people because it's very clear, right? If you pray the prayer, I get to count you on my scorecard. If you go to this group, I get to count you. If you then have another conversation with someone else, Oh, now I can say that like, we're discipling too deep, right? And it's like, it's very, it's very codified. And we, we measure the numbers. And, and I think that part of the problem with progressive faith is that like, we can't do any of that. Like, I can't promise you the easy fix. I can't promise you that you will be healed. I can't promise you that your grief will go away tomorrow. I can't promise you that like this prayer is going to fix your life. Yeah, you feel better. And like, what do we do with that? So that's some of what I've been experiencing and thinking through. And I have more thoughts, but what does that stir up in you? Right? Yeah. Well, just like the like, the wanting the easy fix, I've been having like a lot of mental health stuff the past few weeks. And like, today I was like, this is I know this is crazy, but I was like, I'm on a Monwell butron. And I'm, there's like three levels. There's 150, 300, 450. And that's the highest it goes. And today, and I only had 300 pills, that's what I'm on. And today I had the thought like, at like, 30, 30 afternoon, I was like, maybe if I just like took another pill, like that would make like that, that would be the fix. And I was like, that's crazy. Like that is like, it was like double. You've like never been on the Dose that has absolutely like, don't do that. Like, you're not a doctor like, go make an appointment with your like, high interest. This is like, this is like not the move. And then I had that thought. And God bless my husband. He came over like, I'd fucking angel, like maybe five minutes later and was like, Hey, you're like kind of in love with a whole like Intel, like, let's go for a walk outside. And like, it didn't solve everything. I'm still kind of like my head is creary, but like I put on my shoes and I walked out into the sun and I walked down the road and like, I like, it took some work. So that's the one. And I didn't solve it, but I did something when you were talking about, like, I can't promise you like creepy as complicated. I can't promise you an easy fix. I think about that a lot of my work as a relationship coach with folks who were mostly in or interested in open relationship. And, and usually they were working together because it's a little bit rocky. Like one of them is insecure, jealous, like not sure if they want an open relationship. They're having some communication issues and not having as much sex as they want to be having things like feel a little bit, a lot of my clients are like, things are great, except there's like one area. Some are like, Oh my God, it's on the rocks help. And I also am like, I often find myself saying like, I can we can like work together, but like, here's a tool or here's a framework, but like, this isn't a magic wand. Like it's not going to automatically fix everything. Also like, I can't, I can't promise you that your sex life will be incredible that you won't break out XYZ. I can say, here are the tools that I have to offer. They really work. I have a really high success rate, like success rate traditionally defined in terms of like people getting their spark back and having more sex than they used to be and like feeling much more confident and calm in their open relationships. Like I can look and see like this shit does work. It's not like I didn't make it up. And also like, in the eight years that I've been doing this work, like I can think of like two clients that have like decided they were going to get divorced like while we were working together and both of those people, one of them I continued to work with for like a while after that, he's now been like remarried. Both those people are like, it was worth like it was worth trying to figure it out. It was like worth giving like being openhearted, like showing up and it was like, we're even getting divorce is a success. This is better than the way things were. And so like, I can't, you know, you can't promise someone that their grief pain is going to go away tomorrow. As someone who like lost the heart of my quadris and family, I can tell you that like it will be worth it to like stay in, but just stay in it to like not kill yourself. Please don't kill yourself. I've had a few brands go up, come kill themselves. It's not great. Like it's it will be like worth it to like stay present to your humanity. It will be worth it to stare it in the face. It'll be like worth it to like move through it. You might still be traumatized or harmed. Like healing might not look like eat, pray, love. But the alternative is despair. And like that's that ain't it. Yeah. Yeah. And I think that like, I don't know, there's something in in the sitting in it that I think can be holy. Right. I think about the people that come into my office and it's like, I don't know. We can't we can't again, like fix people's theology in five minutes, either. Which is also part of the problem. But like, you know, there there are times when someone will say like, I know that God had this happen for a reason. And that is one where I try to be like, I don't know that I believe that slash that's not the God that I believe in. Yeah. But one of the things that I will often say if they will let me is like, what I do believe is that the divine was was with you in it and and remains with you in it. And I think like we can also say like, in the grief of losing a loved one, right? Like, I do believe like God is present in that suffering. And like the point of incarnation is that like God suffers with us. And I also believe like if that doesn't resonate with you, like there is a something of like, you are at least in community with like all of the other people who loved this person and and that there is something holy in in that like you are not alone in and even if even if you are if this is a friend or a family member that like no one else knew like you were you were at least not alone in your grieving in that other people are grieving all over the world. Like if that if nothing else like that reminds you that you were connected to other people, like I think that there is something holy in that too. And I think too about like the times of my life, I remember so distinctly when I was going through what I would now call my deconstruction my my really like my unraveling was like an unraveling of everything. And how often I wanted someone to just give me the fucking answer. Like, tell me what to believe. Tell me how to fix this. Tell me how to like stop believing all of these things that are hurting me and to like start believing the things that are good for me. And now looking back, I'm so grateful and this you know, I will say that like this is like two decades on that I can say this. Yes. Had you asked me a decade and a half ago, I would not be having I would not be saying this like yeah, two decades on I can say I'm so grateful for the struggle of it all because there is no part of my faith that has been untouched by the struggle, which also means that there is no part of the faith that I continue to hold that is that has not been weighed and tested and found worthy, which does not believe but it does not mean that I have it all figured out. There are still pieces of my faith that I'm like, oh, I am still confronting that or or I'm learning new information or like I'm uncovering new ways to read scripture or or I'm going into a different kind of relationship with the divine as I get older and I uncover new things about myself in the world. But like I'm so grateful for the the immense struggle, which was not months, right? It was years. Yeah. Because I think it has made my faith so much more deep and profound and mine, right? Like there's no there's nothing that I'm believing because someone told me to, right? Like all of the things that I will say that I believe now are because like I actually believe them and I have reasons for it. And like and that was painful, right? And I think that like the the shitty thing is, it is not it is not a great campaign slogan to be like, come join progressive faith, you will suffer, but it will be worth it. And also, yeah, that is kind of the message of gospels, right? Like, yeah, take up your cross and follow me probably gonna lose your life. But at least you like died for something worthy. And so again, like, not the thing you probably want on a like pithy billboard. It doesn't go well with a three chord progression, rock, yeah, song and worship space. Yeah. And also, like, it feels much more human and much more real. And and it feels a lot less like spiritual gaslighting. Like, I heard someone say something today. I thought I'm not gonna repeat. But that was so bananas to me. That I was like, you are blaming this person's like physical ailment on the fact that like, you don't think they're believing in the right way. Like this is not helpful. This is not helpful. Like, that person is injured. Like this is just not helpful, right? And I think that like this kind of spiritual gaslighting and spiritual bypassing that happens. When when we become a part of a community that demands happiness. And I don't I don't even want to say joy because it's not I don't feel like it's real joy, right? It is it is a demanded happiness. It's a demanded put a smile on it. Like I think that actually robs people of the holiness of the struggle and robs them of like actual spiritual maturity. Yeah, this all reminds me this sort of like wanting to quick fix or the prayer or the blessing or the platitude reminds me of like the we get a lot of messages asking for like a queer inclusive Bible translation. And like, I really hate to be the bearer about news. But like a queer inclusive Bible translation is like not going to heal your religious baggage or religious trauma. And it's like not going to heal like your uncertainty about your gender or your body, your shame around around sex. And but it was like not to judge that like the desire for that because I also like when I was realizing that I was queer and trying to square that with Christianity, I didn't I couldn't even comprehend that there would be a queer inclusive Bible translation that that maybe that that would exist. But I but I did like look in the Bible. I wanted my team and I be teen study box to tell me it was okay. And when that didn't tell me it was okay, I went searching on the internet to try to find articles that would tell me that it was okay. And I and here's the thing like I did find some right like I came across a bunch of articles I probably read Tony and Peggy Campolo. At some point I read Jesus, the Bible and homosexual day by Jack Rogers. And that I don't want to say that like that was helpful. But I can look back now in many ways and be like, Oh, that was a band aid. The one of the most powerful things I could do for myself to realize that it was okay to be queer was to like see my queer self in the Bible and be like, Oh, I'm not like there wasn't a Adam and it wasn't actually Adam and Steve. But like in I like I years ago at Seattle Pacific, I told the story and then it's now become like one of my go to go to stories. It's in our book reading the Bible, the queer eyes. Like I I like found this connection between this experience that I had with my very first ever boyfriend, being at this park near our house and going on these walks and it really feeling like a like a sanctuary. And then this was like the early it was like 2004. So like leaving that park and being out back in sort of the quote unquote real world and that feeling really like scary and dangerous and homophobic and not just in the context of like Christianity or religion, but just like at my secular high school, it was like not okay to be gay. It was just like a rough time to be to be gay and really feeling like banished it be like being banished from Eden leaving this business, this National Park near our homes and being like, Oh, this, like, but I had Ben's hand, hand in my hand. And being like, Oh, this must have been what Adam felt like looking at even like a bone in my bone flesh in my flesh. And then like just sort of like picking at that and then being in Brooklyn and seeing like, Oh, this is like the early church, like, Oh, like, it's not it's like not okay to be gay. It's clip that it's not okay to be gay. It's actually like deeply good and holy and sacred. And like that is it feels like maybe like semantics, but like the work of being like, Oh, I have a place in faith, I can like see myself reflected in sacred text queerness has like something to teach straight people about their faith like the queer queers everywhere, but I don't have experience with queers everywhere like queers and in Brooklyn are like taking better like are being a better model of the early church than most evangelical churches out there. I mean, a lot of evangelical churches, they actually do quite a good job of like taking care of the material needs of their people. So maybe it's like queers in Brooklyn are doing better job of being the church than a lot of progressive churches even right. And so like it, there wasn't just like a prayer that like there wasn't like an inverse like sinners prayer, I can't be like I accept Jesus into my heart like I accept like, I accept the gay spirits of hikes, I like I accept Marsha P Johnson into my heart and now, now I feel better. It was work of wrestling with the Bible, like journaling, seeing like drawing connections, talking to queer elders doing activism, like taking up traditional sacred practices again and being like, what, what if I really let like communion speak to me like what what's going on there? I met leading Christianity becoming Jewish at some point and like, like taking on like that, but those practices and like I think back to my 16 year old self, like in my bedroom on the computer googling, like, can you be Christian? And all of that work that I just described is so so much more soothing and meaningful to me than any article or book that I ever read. Yeah, and I think that part of the the work then right is to become willing to, to like cherish and embrace the struggle, right? I think about this with creative work too, right? And I know we just did an episode on AI a couple of weeks ago, but we didn't really talk about creativity that bright, but there's there's folks who like, are wanting to to just like pop a prompt into AI and have it write the novel that they have been dreaming about. But like, the joy of of creativity is like the struggle, the struggle with trying to get the thing that you like envisioned in your head out in the world, like with your own hands and heart and minds. And like, if you take the struggle away, you also, I think, take some of the humanity away. And like, I think we're going to see that with like AI art that it is, it is the only soul that is in it is the soul that it has like stolen from the artists whose work have been fed into these large language models. And so I think that like, for me, what I would encourage folks is to like find ways that you can sit with and become not just okay with discomfort, but like that that that struggling becomes like the thing that fuels you. And I think part of what part of what made it easier for me is when I stopped believing, well, when I stopped believing in hell, that really helped, right? Because like, you could you could then like, if I believe the wrong thing, God is not going to smite me. Yes, like that is maybe step one. But also, when I stopped believing that there was like one right way to do anything and everything, that became a really helpful space, right? That I definitely believe like there there are ways that we can get it wrong, right? Whether that is like with creativity or with reading the Bible or with like our interactions with other people. Yeah. But I think a almost everything is forgivable and be like, if there's no one right way to do it, then it lets us off the hook to try some things, right? We can we can try out beliefs, we can try out reading different translations, we can try out different ways of being in community, we can try out different rituals and ways of worship and like find out what resonates and that that too becomes part of the journey, right? And part of the joy in the journey of like, I'm going to try some things and I'm going to see what feels good and right and fun and meaningful. Yeah, if you want to do some of this like wrestling wrestling in community with people who are like who get it if you want to like find some spiritual practices that work for you and soothe you heal you connect you to your queries connect you to something bigger than yourself. If you want to maybe even sort of like step back towards like reclaiming the Bible. We have workshops for all three of those areas inside of sanctuary colle