omnist.world

Deutsch

Zen · Compare this tradition with another

Zhao Zhou’s Instructions for Finding Our True Home

Upaya Zen Center Santa Fe - Dharma Podcast · Upaya Zen Center Santa Fe - Dharma Podcast · 2026-10-26 · Santa Fe · Source

Humility · main message Repentance · carrying Knowledge · carrying

Wahres spirituelles 'Verlassen des Zuhauses' besteht im Loslassen egoistischer Ansprüche und intellektueller Konzepte, nicht im physischen Verzicht auf materiellen Besitz.

Nicht nach einem Anspruch streben, nicht nach Verunreinigungen suchen.

Der Text beleuchtet die Lehren des Zen-Meisters Zhaozhou (Jōshū) aus der Tang-Dynastie, insbesondere dessen Koans zum Thema 'das Verlassen des Zuhauses'. Die Sprecherin Cynthia Kier erläutert, dass dieser Begriff im Buddhismus nicht primär den physischen Verzicht auf weltlichen Besitz oder den Palast des Buddha meint, sondern das Loslassen innerer Anhaftungen und intellektueller Konzepte. Zhaozhou wird als Vorbild für geistige Flexibilität und Unabhängigkeit dargestellt, der sich nicht an äußeren Formen oder Statusclout festhielt. Die Kernaussage ist, dass wahres 'Verlassen des Zuhauses' darin besteht, nicht mehr nach einem egoistischen Anspruch zu streben und die Weisheit zu nutzen, statt von ihr benutzt zu werden. Der Text verbindet diese historischen Lehren mit der zeitgenössischen Praxis im westlichen Buddhismus und betont die Notwendigkeit, sich von festen Identitäten und Erwartungen zu lösen.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Clinging, desire, the inability to let go; Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality
Where does the evil reside?
in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual
What helps against it?
contentment, fasting, voluntary sacrifice, letting go; insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding
What is human being according to this text?
entangled in deception or desire, but capable of being set free
Where is history heading?
the message stands outside of history
What does the text base its claim on?
on tradition, the fathers, an established practice; on the founder or prophet of the tradition
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
to one's own fellow believers
Where is the text's criticism directed?
at one's own community and at oneself

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Measured

Basic stance
1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
2 of 3
Reach
1 of 5
Concreteness
2 of 3
Boundary
0 of 3
Time
past 3, present 2, future 0

Analysed with qwen/qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
Thank you for listening to UPIA's Dharma podcast, an extraordinary series of talks from some of the finest teachers in the world. I'm Joan Halifax, founder of the UPIA's End Center, and we're happy to make these podcasts available to you. Please consider making a donation so we can offer these recordings freely. You'll find a donation button on our podcast page. And thank you so much. This is Dharma Podcast at DharmaPodcast.org This is episode number 2682. It was recorded on October 21st, 2026. And it is titled, Zhaozhou's Instructions for Finding Our True Home. The speaker for this episode is Cynthia Kier. That's set to military time. I think I'll be able to translate it. Good evening, everyone. Welcome. Anyone here for the first time to UPIA? Okay, welcome. And others who might not be acknowledging it. Oh, bless you, a bodhisattva for sure. I want to express my appreciation before getting started and before having all the papers fly. To all of you for coming tonight and co-creating a very lovely warm and full sangha here. To the maha sangha as always. To all of the participants in the sushin. I think we have about 50 people here all sitting. We're in our fourth day, I think, of sitting in silence from 6am to 8.45. Not nonstop, although you can't convince my knees of that. But that's a different matter. And appreciation to the local sangha. Always a joy to see you and to be with you. And to Roshi. I think you're in Japan, but love and gratitude to you. So we've been studying this particular period and person in China during the Tang dynasty. And the person that we are studying is Zhao Zhou or Zhou Shu, the Japanese name. And he is notable, just a little background for those of you who might not be, have been in practice period or sushin. He's notable for perhaps having the most number of koans being put in the formal collection of koans. And I think that he has in his life there were like over 500 koans that were collected. I want to talk about a particular topic that he addressed among all these koans, which are quite varied and diverse in many of the things that they address. But I'm struck by the fact that there are quite a few koans that address this concept of leaving home. So from the time of Buddha, leaving his palace, I see that this is not going to necessarily work for me. Leaving home has been a hallmark of our practice. And I'm sure all of you are familiar with the general story of Buddha leaving home in the middle of the night, leaving this palatial setting, this royal and rather pampered life, to go off in pursuit of his spiritual quest to find out what was the nature of suffering, how to transform suffering, and ultimately how to find freedom. And it's called the great renunciation, this action of his. And it remains to this day a very powerful metaphor for those of us who follow in these footsteps. It's quite something for many of us to think about someone leaving that level of comfort, privilege, wealth, security, in order to go out onto an unknown path, seeking these things that are, might seem rather ethereal. So as he embarked on his spiritual quest, it is said that he cut his long hair. He traded in his very fine robes for simple, his very fine garments for simple robes. And this remains a very, very potent metaphor for all of us then and now. Even as the nature of it has changed over the 2600 years or so since he lived. So Zhou, Zhou, Zhou, Zhou, Zhou, Zhou, Zhou, Zhou, we'll just go with that. Also had a similar, had similar elements in his story and in his journey. Living in China and the northern part of China in the 700s and 800s, he entered the monastery at a very, very young age. And before he was to be ordained, he actually had this awakening, if you will, but the awakening wasn't like the type of awakening we talk about in practice. It was more just a came to some clarity that this was not for him, this particular monastery, this particular practice was just not speaking to him. It was not landing well. He did not feel completely engaged with it. And so he's a very, very young person. He's an adolescent. I think he's maybe 17, maybe somewhere in that range. And so showing a lot of independence of mind, but also flexibility. He decides to leave and he goes on a pilgrimage. And on that pilgrimage, he finds the person who is to become his primary teacher. We might call it in my lineage, we might call it his hard teacher, Nankuan or Nansen. And at this time, Nankuan is living in the mountains in a very, very simple setting, living a very simple life. And they click almost right away and Giaozhou spends the next almost 40 years with this man as his master in collaboration, working with him, living in these mountains. So already he has left home, he's gone to the monastery, he's left the monastery. Now he's left the monastery and he's gone to the forest. And then toward the end of Nankuan's life, maybe about the last seven or eight years, he finds favor from the local governor of the province. And the governor builds for him or gives him a kind of a more upscale type of a monastery where he moves and Giaozhou moves with him. And for the rest of Nankuan's life, about seven or eight years, he lives there in this different type of monastery setting. And when Nankuan dies, he says that the monastery for about three years, and then he decides, and now he's about 56 or 60, he decides that he is going to go on pilgrimage and just travel across China. And he does this for 20 years. So I'm feeling a person who is very flexible, very open-minded and very curious, very curious, right? And not really tied to a lot of the trappings that we can easily get tied to. Sometimes people come into practice and they want one of those. They don't understand what it means to get involved in the trappings of practice. Clearly, he is fleet of foot when it comes to those sorts of things. So he travels for 20 years, mostly visiting other teachers, finding out, you know, sharing notes, sharing stories. And then he lands, again, back in northern China, and he is given, comes into possession of a monastery that is, to call it humble, I think would be generous. Word has it, or the record says that it had, the monks hall had maybe two walls, that there were donkeys in the front yard, that there were rats crawling over, and most everyone was wearing very tattered robes. So I'm very struck by this about him. You know, it strikes me that this is a very interesting person who can, oh, and by the way, he lives to 120 years. And over these 120 years, we just see this incredible fluidity and flexibility in him as his journey is the testament to. So he settles in this monastery and lives there for the rest of his life and is frequently visited by students, by, you know, people that are making pilgrimage, whatever. So among the koans, as I said, that he has, that are recorded and saved, there's a cluster that relate to this notion that we first see in Buddha of leaving home. And it is, to this day, as I said, a pretty strong metaphor and principle in our own contemporary practice. So let me just read you a few of these koans and then we can talk about the notion of leaving home. A monk asked, Jiao Jiao, what is leaving home? The master said, not aspiring to a claim, not seeking after defilements. So a very straightforward answer, very straightforward koan where it's like, if you think that, you know, wearing something different is going to elevate you, right? You're going to be better if that's what you're seeking in this practice. You're on the wrong track. And if you are doing that, you have just moved from one house of ego to another house of ego and you have missed the opportunity to find liberation and freedom. We have in our lineage to this day these ceremonies, Jukai, which many of you have had, which is called frequently, staying at home while attaining the way. And it has typically been a householder path. And then we have what we call Shukai Tokudo, which is the priest path prior to Dharma transmission. And we call that leaving home to attain the way. But over the centuries, for a variety of reasons, particularly here in the contemporary Western setting of Buddhism, this idea of leaving home has really changed quite a lot. In terms of what it really means. And I think that Xiao-Xiao was really a precursor in terms of understanding this and also giving us a very clear sense of what it truly means to leave home whatever your role or might be. So here's another one. A monk asked, it is not yet clear to me about what about it is when someone vows to leave home and search for supreme wisdom. The master said, if you have not left home, wisdom uses you. After leaving home, you use wisdom. So if you are stuck in your concept about what it means to leave home, to be a monk, to be a bodhisattva, to take this path, then you have not left home. Right? You are still deep in your concept and your attachment to that. By staying at home, what he is implying is that we are still clinging to intellectual ideas and concepts of what it means to practice, of what it means to be a monk, to have jukkai, to have shukka, to kudou, to be a sincere practitioner, to be a follower of the way. Another one. A monk asks, what is leaving home? The master says, how have you managed to meet me? Right? Again, a very straight forward kind of humorous take somebody down a peg or two. I mean, the students often come forward with either lofty ideas or actually very sincere ideas. Help, please. And he has a way of just diverting them from their intellectual concept of wanting to hang out in that place, drop an anchor on an intellectual idea, and stay there. I feel that he is like very deft at spiritual aikido. Right? And he just deflects the student and the question away from this intellectual energy that they have, predisposition they have to something that is right here, right now, and opposite them what they expect. Okay, this is the, maybe the last one. A monk asks, does a man who has left home become a householder or not? The master said, to leave home is to be a monk, but I don't pay attention to either leaving home or not leaving home. The monk said, why don't you pay attention? The master said, to do so is to leave home. To not pay attention is to leave home. When I don't pay attention to leaving or not leaving is to leave. There are a lot of leaves in there, but I'm feeling like you all are keeping up with this. Okay, good. And then last one. What about it when someone vows to leave home and search for the way? The student asks. And he answers or questions, what home are you leaving? What home are you leaving? It's not just an act of leaving a physical setting. It's not just an act of shaving your head. It's not just an act of sowing your robe. And for those who are not in the formal structure, this applies to you too. It's not just an act of coming to a sashane or being in a practice period. The request is actually much deeper, much more difficult than something like that. So whether you're a monk or a priest or not, I think that this is what he is pointing to for a long time. What I'm pointing to for any sincere practitioner is that we have to go through this process of leaving home if we are to truly experience the liberation that is implicit in our practice. If we do not go through that dharma gate, we will not find the transformation that we are hoping for, that we are practicing toward. I think this is a quote from Thomas Merton. Buddhist meditation, but above all that of Zen, seeks not to explain but to pay attention, to become aware, to be mindful. In other words, to develop a certain kind of consciousness that is not taken in so easily by words, by habits, or by our reactions. So when I think of how most of us are, rather, if we were to be standing watching Buddha leaving the palace with all of its wonders, safety, and all the things we imagine and project on the palace, probably unlike Buddha leaving, we would be wanting to catapult over the walls to get on the inside. Let me be safe, let me feel secure, let me have privilege of whatever sort. And because we can't do that, I think this is one of the reasons why we build conceptual palaces in our minds. That if left unexamined, actually become conceptual, or palaces, don't become palaces, but rather become conceptual prisons. So we go about this process, I think, in part because it's just part of our society. Several of us have made this comment that words are our currency. This is what we use to express ourselves, to communicate with each other, to connect, to get things done. And yet there's an inherent danger in words, in using them, relying only on words. Because words can absolutely hijack us from our direct experience of this moment in just a matter of seconds. We will start to trust the words, or follow the words, or let the words lead the story, rather than our heart, minds, and bodies in terms of what we are actually experiencing. And some of this is, you know, totally embedded in our culture. I mean, I think if you reflect on the types of questions that you might be asked by people you know, or people you don't know, or the types of questions you ask, they might be things like, what do you do? What do you think? What do you like? Questions that are specifically geared toward getting, activating the mind, and getting us all into a concept, right? So it becomes habit energy to dwell and to live and to reside in this very limited, almost singular, plain kind of way with our minds. It was interesting. I was talking with somebody today who was down by the river, both yesterday and today, and just enjoying having this direct experience of life, right? Just being open, free of concepts, which is a rare thing for us, a glorious moment in our experience. The river, the sound of the river, these gorgeous golden leaves, the green, the mountains, the sky. Just having a fantastic time listening to a bird. And all of a sudden a very nice stranger comes up with the phone and a Merlin app and says, oh, that's a town since Solitaire. Get out of that experience. You've got to know the concept, right? And then the next day, also down at the river, was just enjoying the leaves on the ground. And somebody comes up and says, those are cottonwood leaves. I so appreciated that, you know, it's just an example of how slippery the hill is that we stand on in terms of trying to have our direct experience, right? Even if we manage to actually arrive there in that experience, there are going to be other people that immediately will put a little poke in it. So I think that there's just, you know, kind of, it's inculcated in our society. We're paid, we're trained, we go to school to use this, to use this, we're paid, you know, in order to think. And it becomes, as I said, just a prison that shuts us off from so much of what is available to experience in our lives, in each moment of our lives. And then there's habit energy, the type of things that, you know, might have happened to us, might appear up in our minds because of the particular karmic crucible that we're born into, right? We all are born into unique karmic crucibles. So depending upon that, the causes and conditions there, we're going to get all kinds of messages. If it's an intellectual karmic crucible, it might be, you know, oh, you need to go to school, you need to get a PhD, you need to be smart. If it's an unskillful karmic crucible, it might be messages of not being enough, of being a burden of neglect, right? It doesn't really matter what your karmic crucible is, but those messages are going to, you're going to be marinating in them for many years. Then you're just going to believe them to be true and strengthen them yourself. And that is a very powerful experience, another form of a conceptual prison. And that's, of course, the task of working through our karma and understanding our karma. And some of it, I think, just comes from the fact that, you know, we're wired to be reactive and a lot of reactivity immediately takes us to heightened states of emotions and ideas. And the adrenaline flows, and if there's any precursor of any activity that activates us, then it's even more so. We get just suddenly really wrapped around the wheel really tight. And in that moment, the adrenaline, with all of these, we think that what's happening in our minds is true. And sometimes it's a little true, right? But not always, not always, right? So this reactivity, Buddha called the waterfall. And I think it's a good term and a good metaphor for all of these various ways, the ones that I've identified and the ones I haven't, that are myriad of living in a concept prison and being cut off from our life. And in this waterfall metaphor, what he is pointing at is that when we get into our reactivity, we get caught under the waterfall and we're swept away. We're swept away from this moment. We're swept away from this life, this breath, which is all we ever have, really. I mean, I wish us all well as we leave this hall, but who knows? Who knows, right? And that is something that Buddhism is very aware of in permanence. We have chance and we have almost every night, you know? Do not squander your life. Wake up. Life is fleeting, quickly passing. Do not waste time. At any rate, so all of this building of conceptual palaces, they turn into prisons and they just turn into prisons. They just leave us and living our lives in a very narrow way. And, you know, for years I have to say this is where I lived. These three inches up here. And I had all kinds of thoughts and they were great thoughts. And the more I'm in practice, the more I realize they were just sorry ass empty ideas, but that's okay. But all of this and more, and this is the genius of Buddhism. All of this can be changed. They are not stuck in concrete even though they can become concretized. I was sitting at the Buddha hall where lectures are given at San Francisco Zen Center one Saturday morning. And Blanche Hartman was giving a lecture on Jukai, which is the initial process of entering into the lineage and taking the precepts. And she was talking about what we do and as a person coming from a different religious tradition, I was so interested in what was not going to be asked of this person. There was not going to be any vow of celibacy. There was not going to be any vow of obedience. There was not going to be any vow of poverty. And so I asked her, I said, well, what is it that we are renouncing then if we're not renouncing these things? And she said, we are renouncing our fixed ideas, which is a 24-7, 365 practice, right? It will keep us off the streets and out of trouble for sure. So when we start to engage in this practice, it begins by taking this all important backward step to actually realize that what is going through our minds, all of these concepts that we have built that we've so enjoyed, I mean, some of them have been delightful in my life and fun. And some of you, maybe many of you very heady people have enjoyed many of the concepts that you've studied. And I'm not trying to turn off, turn us away from that. I'm just trying to point to the fact like Jiaozhou that there's more. And if that is the only place we are living, we are missing quite a lot. So we take the backward step and begin to observe in earnest with neutrality and with kindness how our mind works. What are our default settings? Where are the places that we go time and time again? Is our mind usually racy and speedy or does it tend to go slow? What are these persistent thoughts that enter our head? You know, I will say that mostly being in Zen and talking about this and working with people who are in Zen, they usually are not about arrogance. They're usually on the other end of the spectrum. Not worthy. Not good enough. Don't know enough about Buddhism. Not a good enough practitioner. Don't spend enough time in Zaza and don't have a teache