omnist.world

Deutsch

Vaishnava · Compare this tradition with another

Are We All Born Atheists, and Is Belief in God Forced Upon Us Later?

no name given · Gita Daily (Chaitanya Charan Das) · 2026-10-30 · Pune · Source

Knowledge · main message Humility · carrying

Die Annahme, Glaube sei unnatürlich, beruht auf einer falschen Definition von 'natürlich'; die menschliche Fähigkeit, Sinn zu suchen und von anderen zu lernen, macht die Entwicklung theistischer Überzeugungen zu einem natürlichen Teil der intellektuellen Reifung.

Die Tatsache, dass wir nicht mit einer Überzeugung geboren werden, bedeutet nicht, dass es unnatürlich ist, sie zu glauben. Was zählt, ist, ob wir gute Gründe haben, diese Überzeugung anzunehmen.

Der Text diskutiert die These, ob Menschen als Atheisten geboren werden und der Glaube an Gott ihnen später aufgezwungen wird. Der Sprecher widerlegt dies mit dem '3D-Rahmenwerk': Definition des Natürlichen, Entwicklung des Potenzials und Neigung zum Lernen. Er argumentiert, dass die Fähigkeit zur Transzendenz und Sinnfindung ein natürliches menschliches Potenzial ist, das sich durch Bildung und kulturelle Überlieferung entfaltet. Der Sprecher betont, dass Lernen von anderen Generationen ein natürlicher Teil der menschlichen Entwicklung ist, der auch für die Übernahme von Weltanschauungen gilt. Er unterscheidet zwischen ungesundem sozialem Druck und gesundem, begründetem Nachdenken über Überzeugungen. Als Beispiel für letzteres zitiert er die Bhagavad Gita, die zur freien, überlegten Wahl einlädt. Der Text schließt mit der persönlichen Erfahrung des Sprechers, der durch das Studium von Wissenschaftlern und philosophischen Texten zum Glauben fand.

Worldview

what this means
What, according to this text, is the root of the evil?
Ignorance, illusion, a false view of reality
Where does the evil reside?
in the heart, the will, or the soul of the individual
What helps against it?
insight, learning, enlightenment, right understanding; personal experience, testimony, encounter with God or with people
What is human being according to this text?
self-determined, the author of one's own actions
Where is history heading?
it is getting better, development towards the good
What does the text base its claim on?
on argument, logic, science; on personal experience, testimony, encounter
To whom does the text's call for devotion apply?
to every human being, regardless of faith
Where is the text's criticism directed?
at others, at society, at other groups

Related texts from other traditions

by similarity of the analysis, one text per tradition

What the text calls for

Passages cited

Bhagavad Gita 18.63

Measured

Basic stance
1 from -2 to 2
Insistence
2 of 3
Reach
5 of 5
Concreteness
2 of 3
Boundary
0 of 3
Time
past 2, present 2, future 1

Analysed with qwen/qwen3.8-27b, version v3. The same standards apply to every tradition, see Values.

Show the full text
“Are We All Born Atheists, and Is Belief in God Forced Upon Us Later?” This was a question a young man asked me after a youth camp for IIT Chennai students. We were at a beachside resort, with the ocean visible through a window behind us. The student was a scholarly-looking young man with a small mustache and thick glasses. “Is this a question you’ve been thinking about yourself, or did someone else raise it?” I asked. “I came across a clip on social media where this issue was raised at an atheist conference,” he replied. “I wanted to know how to respond to it.” “Yes, I’ve encountered this argument before and have thought about it,” I replied. “I generally approach it through three Ds: Definition of Natural, Development of Potential, and Disposition to Learn.” What Does It Mean to Be Natural? “The first D is Definition of Natural,” I explained. “The argument assumes that whatever we’re born with is natural, while whatever we learn later is somehow less natural. But why should we accept that assumption? “We are born without knowledge of language, without knowledge of science, and without even a developed understanding of logic—including the very logic being used in this argument. Does that mean learning language, developing scientific knowledge, or refining our logical abilities is unnatural? “But that confuses two different meanings of natural: what we’re born with and what we have the potential to develop. “Many of our most important abilities aren’t fully developed when we’re born. They develop as we grow, learn, and interact with others. Something doesn’t become unnatural simply because we aren’t born with it in a fully developed form. “So why apply this reasoning selectively to our theistic development?” “But if we don’t define natural as something we’re born with, how would we define it?” he asked. “That brings us to the second D: Development of Potential,” I replied. “Instead of asking only whether we’re born with something, we can ask whether we’re born with the potential to develop it. “Just as humans have the potential to learn language, develop scientific knowledge, and refine their logical abilities, we also have the ability to conceive of something far bigger than ourselves—something beyond our immediate existence, something transcendent. “Our minds are basically meaning-seeking or meaning-making machines. We need to make sense of life. The arts, sciences, religions, and philosophies of the world are all, in different ways, attempts to make sense of life. “Of course, the ways in which we try to make sense of life may or may not actually make sense. But the need to seek explanations and understand our place in the larger scheme of things is deeply ingrained in who we are as human beings. “Now, consider what it means to say that a newborn baby doesn’t believe in God. A newborn baby may not even have a clear concept of its own mother’s existence. It certainly doesn’t have a developed understanding of the laws of physics, even though those laws govern its existence. “The baby experiences the world, but its ability to consciously question what exists and what doesn’t exist is yet to develop. “So to call a newborn baby an atheist because it doesn’t believe in God is to impose a philosophical category on someone who hasn’t yet developed the capacity to understand or evaluate that category. “Of course, if atheism is defined merely as the absence of belief in God, we may technically apply that label to a newborn. But such a label tells us little about whether atheism is more natural or reasonable than theism. The baby lacks not just belief in God but developed beliefs about countless other realities. “As our capacities develop, we begin asking questions about the world, our existence, and the possibility of realities beyond what we can immediately perceive. “Theists and atheists may arrive at different answers to these questions. Which worldview helps us make better sense of life is a separate debate. But the capacity to ask such questions, including questions about transcendence, is a natural part of human intellectual development.” Is Belief in God Forced Upon Us? “But isn’t belief in God forced upon us by society?” he asked. “I think forced is too harsh a word to use as a general description,” I replied. “It’s judgmental and sweeping. That brings us to the third D: Disposition to Learn. “One thing that distinguishes us humans from other species is how much we can learn from others, not just from our own experiences. And we can pass that learning on from one generation to the next.” “But don’t other species also learn from one another?” he asked. I nodded. “Yes. But we humans have become exceptionally good at building on what earlier generations learned and passing that knowledge on through language, education, and culture. “If every generation had to discover everything independently, without learning from previous generations, we would be condemned to reinvent the wheel repeatedly. “So the fact that theism is taught doesn’t, by itself, make it unnatural. Teaching and learning are themselves natural parts of human life. “Indeed, if we were to reject everything taught to us simply because we weren’t born knowing it, we would have to reject much of what makes human civilization possible. “And if we were to insist that our condition at birth should determine our worldview throughout life, why should atheists try to persuade theists to change their beliefs? Why should anyone try to convince anyone else of anything? Newborn babies don’t engage in philosophical debates about what exists and what doesn’t exist. “The very act of debating theism and atheism presupposes intellectual capacities that we weren’t born possessing in a developed form.” “But doesn’t society sometimes pressure people to believe in God?” he asked. “Yes, that can certainly happen,” I replied. “In traditional theistic societies, there may have been considerable social pressure to accept theism. But the reverse has also happened. In communist countries such as Soviet Russia and China, governments have tried to impose atheism and suppress religious belief. Yet theism survived those pressures and, in significant ways, rebounded. “So social pressure can operate in either direction. The real issue isn’t whether a belief is theistic or atheistic, but whether people are being compelled to accept it without examining it. “Forcing any belief on someone is unhealthy. But acquiring beliefs through reasoned deliberation is desirable. And a society that supports such deliberation, rather than suppressing it, is doing something valuable. “The Bhagavad Gita itself gives us a good example. Krishna explains His teachings to Arjuna in considerable detail. He doesn’t merely demand that Arjuna conform to His opinion. After explaining His teachings, Krishna tells him in Bhagavad Gita 18.63: “Vimṛśyaitad aśeṣeṇa yathecchasi tathā kuru. “‘Deliberate on all this fully, and then act as you desire.’ “Krishna gives Arjuna food for thought and invites him to make a considered choice. The Gita thus shows us how spiritual guidance can engage our intelligence rather than bypass it. “So this argument has three problems. It defines natural too narrowly, overlooks how our potentials develop, and ignores how we learn from others. “The fact that we aren’t born believing something doesn’t mean that believing it is unnatural. What matters is whether we have good reasons for accepting that belief.” “This is a very persuasive answer. Thank you very much,” he said before departing. How I Came to Believe in God Later, as I reflected on this conversation, I thought about my own journey from atheism to theism. I was born in a Brahmin family and studied in a Christian convent school. Yet during my ninth grade, I went through a phase of atheism. I distinctly remember telling my English teacher that I didn’t believe in God. Nobody criticized me for expressing that view. During my reading of the biographies of scientists, I came across some striking points. Two such statements by prominent scientists influenced me so strongly that I memorized them. Newton, reflecting on the order he observed in the universe, wrote: “This most beautiful System of the Sun, Planets, and Comets, could only proceed from the counsel and dominion of an intelligent and powerful being.” Carl Friedrich Gauss, a pioneering mathematician and scientist whose contributions extended to electromagnetism, commented on the inspiration that enabled one of his intellectual breakthroughs: “Finally, two days ago, I succeeded—not on account of my hard efforts, but by the grace of the Lord.” These statements made me think about two directions in which we can search for the divine: outward, by observing the remarkable order in the universe, and inward, by reflecting on the intelligence and inspiration through which we understand that order. The philosophical rationale for a theistic worldview came to me later through my study of the Bhagavad Gita. But my initial movement toward belief in God came through reasoned reflection on the reasoning of others—especially pioneering scientists whose intellectual achievements I admired. As I reflected on my journey, it struck me that I had developed the three-D framework primarily as an intellectual response to an atheistic argument, but my own movement toward theism illustrated the third D: my natural disposition to learn from others. I had been free to question God’s existence, and I gradually came to accept it through my own deliberation, informed by what I learned from others. Thinking thus, I offered a prayer: My dear Lord, just as You guided me toward belief in You through the outward observations and inward realizations of thinkers before me, please continue guiding me on my journey toward You. May I grow not only in my belief in You, but also in my trust in You and, ultimately, in my love for You. *** 18.63 Thus I have explained to you knowledge still more confidential. Deliberate on this fully, and then do what you wish to do. The post Are We All Born Atheists, and Is Belief in God Forced Upon Us Later? first appeared on Chaitanya Charan Das, Bhagavad Gita ISKCON .