Zum Inhalt springen
omnism.si

Liberal · Diese Tradition mit einer anderen vergleichen

Unexamined Wounds

ohne Namen · Central Synagogue New York - Predigten · 2026-11-13 · New York · Quelle

Dieser Inhalt ist noch nicht ausgewertet.

Wortlaut anzeigen
Transcript This week, Isaac and Rebekah’s dream is realized, and they conceive. The twins, Jacob and Esau, are born. The next thing we know is that they grow up and become two very different men. We read: “Esau became a hunter, a man of the field, but Jacob was a simple man, staying among the tents.” We learn even more about the differences between these twin brothers. Esau is strong. A provider. Direct. Jacob is mild-mannered. Domestic. Cunning. The question naturally arises: is this nature or nurture? Do these twin boys have inherently different characters, or are these differences fostered by their home and upbringing? The closer we look, the more we see Torah pointing us toward the home. We next read “Isaac loved Esau… while Rebekah loved Jacob.” Isaac and Rebekah have favorites among their twin sons. We would naturally expect the children to react to this favoritism. But, many commentators accept a somewhat simple explanation: Esau, who is loved by his father Isaac, takes on stereotypical masculine traits. Jacob, who is loved by his mother Rebekah, takes on stereotypical feminine traits. Torah is not typically that simplistic. After all, Esau doesn’t learn this machismo behavior from his father’s example. Isaac was a mild and passive child and remains a docile adult. He is not a fighter or a strongman. Isaac is much more like his son Jacob. This makes Isaac’s rejection of Jacob and preference for Esau even stranger. Human nature predisposes us to favor what reminds us of ourselves. This tendency can even show up in how we treat our children. So what causes Isaac to favor Esau who is so unlike him, and why does Esau become a hunter with no one modeling that behavior around him? To understand Isaac, we have to understand the pivotal event of his life. We call this moment: Akeidat Yitzhak - the binding of Isaac. Isaac’s father, Abraham, lied to him, stole him away, tied him up, and attempted to slaughter him as a sacrifice. What must Isaac have felt in that terrible moment? Powerless. Defenseless. Completely at the mercy of someone strong. Betrayed by the person who is meant to protect him, care for him, and keep him safe. What would that experience do to you? What would you do in order to avoid feeling helpless? What would you do in order to never be put in that position again? That leads us to how Esau became the strong hunter. You see, I left out a detail from the verse that describes Isaac and Rebekah’s favoritism. The full verse reads: “Isaac loved Esau because he brought him hunted-game, while Rebekah loved Jacob.” Note that the text says Isaac loves Esau because . That word “because” tells us that Isaac’s love for his son is conditional. It is contingent on his behavior. What type of behavior? The kind Isaac needs in order to feel safe again. During Akeidat Yitzhak, Isaac was powerless, so he will love Esau so long as he is powerful. Isaac was dependent, so he will love Esau as long as he is self-reliant. Isaac was prey, so he will love Esau so long as he is a hunter. The conditionality of his fatherly love was no secret. Esau knew what he needed to do in order to be loved. So Esau warps and bends himself to become the kind of man that could be loved by Isaac. What makes it all even more tragic are the glimpses we see in this week’s reading when Esau’s mask falls. Isaac grows blind. Jacob takes advantage of this blindness and steals the blessing of the first-born. Esau enters his father’s tent ready to finally receive the blessing from his father, only to learn of its theft by his younger brother. He cries, begs his father to help him and to bless him too. In this moment, we see the real Esau. Not a brute, but a boy desperate for his father’s approval. Yet all Isaac can muster in the face of his son’s tears is the retort, “but what can I possibly do for you, my son?” While the Torah tells us Isaac is blind, it never tells us what blinded him. The rabbis connect his blindness to the Akeidah, suggesting that an Angel cried in that moment, and its tear blinded Isaac. Other commentaries teach that Isaac’s blindness was metaphorical and not physical. Perhaps the Torah is communicating that the trauma of Akeidat Yitzhak blinded Isaac to who his sons really were. All Isaac can see is who he requires Esau to become in order to pacify his fear. Esau becomes a tool for Isaac’s drive for safety and protection rather than a child to be loved. Nor can Isaac truly see and love his other son, Jacob. Jacob is too similar, and reminds him of himself, and that reality is terrifying. Loving Jacob would require Isaac to confront his past, and find a way to accept the characteristics within him that allowed him to follow Abraham to that mountain. And so he completely refuses to look upon Jacob lovingly. Isaac’s failure isn’t that he was wounded. It’s that he never faced the wound, so it became the condition of his love, and a controlling force over his life and his family. Everyone is wounded at some point. Life leaves no one unscathed. But what do we do next? Isaac is a cautionary tale of what happens when we leave wounds unexamined. They end up ruling us. Like any good Torah, this isn’t the last word. In parshat Vayishlah, Jacob will break the cycle. He stops running. He returns home. He wrestles in the dark with his past and his pain. He does not walk away healed; he walks away limping. But he walks away able to see in a way his father never could. After his night wrestling, Jacob fully sees himself, and goes on to truly see his brother. Seeing Esau as the man he is rather than the man his father drove him to be was transformative. Jacob says to him, “to see your face is like seeing the face of God.” May we be willing to wrestle with our wounds so that we can dispel their power over us, and love those around us for who they are, and not who we need them to be.