If Devotees Are Satisfied in Krishna, Why Do They Desire to Go to His Abode?
Dieser Inhalt ist noch nicht ausgewertet.
Wortlaut anzeigen
This question was asked of me by a young man after a class in Kolkata, India. We were in a large lecture hall, and most of the fifty or sixty participants had already departed. I was still seated on the āsana, while he sat on a chair provided for people who approached me to have their books signed. He seemed to have read the Bhagavad Gita carefully, as became evident when he elaborated on his question.
“The Bhagavad Gita says in verses 3.17–18 that a self-realized person is completely satisfied within and has no desires. If a devotee is already completely satisfied in Krishna, why should they desire so strongly to go to Krishna’s eternal abode? Shouldn’t they simply be satisfied wherever they are?”
I replied, “That’s a thoughtful question. To understand these verses, we need to consider both their context and their universal meaning.
“First, let’s consider the context. If Bhagavad Gita 3.17–18 meant that we should become so satisfied that we no longer desire anything or do anything, then why should Arjuna fight?
“We may say that Arjuna should fight not out of personal desire but out of an attitude of service to Krishna. And that’s true. But even then, the question remains: Why should one service be preferred or prioritized over another? Why should Arjuna fight rather than simply remain peaceful and absorbed in spiritual consciousness?
“Krishna Himself provides one answer when He explains the importance of maintaining the order and welfare of the world (loka-saṅgraha, 3.20) and, for that purpose, setting an example for others (3.21). He further explains that although He Himself has nothing to gain through action, He still acts for the welfare of the world (3.22–24).
“This shows that being completely satisfied does not mean having no reason to act. We may have nothing to gain personally and still have meaningful reasons to act for the benefit of others. Therefore, contentment does not necessitate the absence of desire, and the presence of desire does not necessarily indicate discontentment.”
He asked, “But isn’t that application limited to that particular situation? Krishna wanted Arjuna to fight a war to establish dharma at that time. How is that relevant for those seeking liberation, which is a goal beyond time?”
I replied, “The particular duty may be specific to Arjuna’s situation, but the underlying principle is timeless: Being spiritually satisfied doesn’t mean having no reason for action or aspiration. This is evident in another passage from the Gita itself.
“In Bhagavad Gita 9.13, Krishna describes the great souls who take shelter of His divine nature:
mahātmānas tu māṁ pārtha
daivīṁ prakṛtim āśritāḥ
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jñātvā bhūtādim avyayam
“The phrase bhajanty ananya-manaso indicates that their minds are exclusively devoted to Krishna. They have understood Krishna to be the supreme reality, the ultimate fulfillment of all their aspirations.
“Yet, in the very next verse (9.14), Krishna says:
satataṁ kīrtayanto māṁ
yatantaś ca dṛḍha-vratāḥ
“These great souls constantly glorify Krishna and endeavor with firm determination.
“If their minds are already completely absorbed in Krishna, why do they still endeavor? And why do they endeavor with such firm determination?”
Looking thoughtful, he said, “Interesting. I hadn’t thought about this. How would you explain it?”
I replied, “Most of us have to work hard just to keep our minds focused on Krishna because we get distracted so easily. But great devotees whose minds are already deeply absorbed in Krishna don’t need as much internal endeavor. Their endeavor is often directed outward, toward expressing their devotion through service.
“A devotee may be completely satisfied in remembering Krishna and yet strive to build a temple for Krishna or travel extensively to share Krishna’s message. Such a devotee is not necessarily acting because something is missing in their own life. They may be acting because they want others to experience the love of Krishna that has already enriched their own lives.
“Let’s understand this through an analogy.
“Consider someone who has been looking for water far and wide across the land and has finally reached the ocean. They are satisfied because they have finally found the water they were seeking. But they may still want to take that water to others.
“Similarly, a devotee who has found fulfillment in Krishna may still endeavor vigorously in this world, not because they are seeking recognition for themselves, but because they want the world to recognize Krishna as the ultimate destination of life.”
He asked, “But my question was about going back to Godhead, to Krishna’s abode. Isn’t it better to keep sharing that fulfillment with others? Why should a devotee want to leave this world?”
I replied, “Devotion can have both an outward aspiration for sharing and an inward aspiration for savoring.
“Let’s take the ocean metaphor further. Someone who has reached the ocean may want to take its water to others. But they may also want to go deeper into the ocean themselves. Reaching the ocean doesn’t mean they have exhausted everything there is to experience within it.
“Similarly, Krishna is the ultimate destination, but He is also the object of endless exploration. His qualities, glories, pastimes, and loving relationships are inexhaustible.
“We see this in the tenth chapter of the Gita. Arjuna accepts Krishna’s position as the Supreme Reality (10.12–13) and fully accepts what Krishna has said (10.14). Yet he still asks to hear more about Krishna’s glories. Krishna responds by describing some of His prominent manifestations, while explaining that His glories have no end (10.19, 10.40).
“Thus, even when we know Krishna to be the ultimate reality, there is always more to know, love, and experience about Him.
“Loving Krishna is both the end of our journey and the journey that knows no end.”
He asked, “But can’t that journey continue in this world itself? Why does a devotee have to go beyond the material world to Krishna’s eternal abode?”
I replied, “Yes, that growth can certainly happen here. But the material world is a place of limitations. Our bodies have limited capacities to serve Krishna, and the world provides limited facilities for serving Him.
“Consider another example. Suppose somebody is so happy that their happiness overflows and they start dancing. They aren’t dancing because they want to become happy. They’re dancing because they’re already happy.
“Now suppose they are in a place where they cannot dance freely, perhaps because the environment is too restrictive. They may want to go somewhere else where they can express their happiness without inhibition.
“Similarly, a devotee may be deeply satisfied in remembering and serving Krishna in this world, yet aspire to go to Krishna’s eternal abode, where that love can be expressed without the limitations imposed by the material body and the material world.
“Such an aspiration doesn’t necessarily arise from dissatisfaction with the present. It can arise from the desire to express more fully the love that is already bringing fulfillment.”
He said, “Yes, that makes sense. But I see many spiritual seekers who want to go back to God’s kingdom simply because this world is so miserable and they want to get out of it. Isn’t that desire coming from dissatisfaction?”
I replied, “Yes, that does happen. And wanting to go to Krishna’s abode primarily to escape worldly suffering is not the purest motivation for devotion. Still, even such an impure motivation can be purified through bhakti.
“The Bhagavatam (2.3.10) encourages everyone—whether free from material desires, filled with desires, or seeking liberation—to worship the Supreme Lord through intense devotion:
akāmaḥ sarva-kāmo vā
mokṣa-kāma udāra-dhīḥ
tīvreṇa bhakti-yogena
yajeta puruṣaṁ param
“So even if someone initially turns toward Krishna because they want relief from suffering, that doesn’t disqualify them from practicing bhakti. As their devotion deepens, however, the desire to escape suffering can become secondary to the desire to love and serve Krishna.
“This purified aspiration is expressed beautifully by Chaitanya Mahaprabhu in His Śikṣāṣṭakam (verse 4):
janmani janmanīśvare
bhavatād bhaktir ahaitukī tvayi
“He prays for causeless devotion to Krishna, birth after birth. He is ready to accept repeated births in this world if that is what Krishna desires, as long as He can continue serving Him.
“Although devotees may desire to go to Krishna’s abode, they never demand that from Krishna. Their desire does not lead to frustration even if it is not fulfilled. They may wish to go to His abode to express their love for Him more fully. But if Krishna wants them to remain in this world and serve Him here, they can accept that without resentment.
“Therefore, satisfaction and aspiration can coexist. Indeed, in bhakti, the deepest satisfaction can become the source of the greatest aspiration.”
He replied, “I always thought that wanting to leave this world meant being so unhappy here that we find it unbearable. But you’ve helped me see that aspiration in a new light. Thank you for such a satisfying answer.”
After he departed, I reflected on what drives my own aspirations in devotion. How pure are those aspirations? How should I strive to purify them? These questions inspired me to pray:
My dear Lord, thank You for bringing me to You, the endless ocean of divine joy. Thank You especially for bringing me to the shore of that ocean where the wisdom of the Bhagavad Gita offers me an entrance into Your inexhaustible reality.
Please let my desire to study the Gita not be driven solely by my intellect’s desire to know more. And please let my desire to share the Gita’s wisdom not be driven solely by my ego’s desire to be known more.
Even if these motivations cannot be immediately eliminated, please let them be subordinated to the higher motivations of loving You and sharing that love with others. And I beg You, O Lord, that one day, in the not-too-distant future, these may become not just my primary aspirations but my exclusive aspirations.
***
09.13 O son of Pṛthā, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible.
The post If Devotees Are Satisfied in Krishna, Why Do They Desire to Go to His Abode? first appeared on Chaitanya Charan Das, Bhagavad Gita ISKCON .