Zum Inhalt springen
omnism.si

Orthodox · Diese Tradition mit einer anderen vergleichen

Can You See the Bad Without Losing Sight of the Good? | 10@9 | 2026.10.26

Rabbi Michael Whitman · Rabbi Michael Whitman (ADATH Congregation, Montreal) - Mining The Riches Of The Parsha · 2026-10-26 · Montreal · Quelle

Dieser Inhalt ist noch nicht ausgewertet.

Wortlaut anzeigen
Good morning. Today is Monday, October 26, 2026. Arabis and Pirkei Avos tell us that we should be, try to be, mi tamidav shall avraham avinu. We should try to be students, followers, disciples of Avraham. And we should try not to be tamidim of bilam, students, disciples, followers of bilam. Of course, bilam was the non-Jewish prophet who was hired by Balak to curse the Jewish people while they were traveling through the desert. And he tried to find a way to curse them, but what came out of his mouth was a blessing. So, Arabis say, be like Avraham and don't be like bilam. In what way? Arabis give several suggestions, but one of them is that we should try to emulate the character of Avraham who had ayin tov, tova, ayin tova, a good eye. And we should try to distance ourselves from the characteristic of bilam who had ayin ra, a bad eye. What is a good eye and a bad eye? I think we tend to imagine to think to ourselves that ayin, tova, a good eye is like naive. Look at the good, see only good, don't look at anything bad, look at only good things. And then an ayin tova would be the opposite of that. Only look for bad things, don't see anything good, only look for bad things. Arabis are telling us be like Avraham and don't be like bilam. But I have an insight to this I want to share with you that is more subtle than that. It's deeper than that. And it's very, very practical. And it comes from someone I've quoted from you recently a couple of times, Dr. Afshin Emrani, who is a cardiologist in Los Angeles. And he understands this by looking back to his own medical training. He writes that when he was training to become a cardiologist, so one of the things he had to learn to do was to be able to read an echocardiogram. Some of us have first hand experience. Echocardiogram is a diagnostic test and a doctor, a specialist will read it to see how the heart is working, if it is working, it's not, what's wrong, what needs to be fixed. And so Dr. Emrani was learning how to be able to read these tests from an older attending physician who had much more experience. Obviously, that's the way you learn. You learn from someone who has more experience and who knew a lot more. And he writes that the training was simple and relentless. Find what's wrong. That is, you're confronted with an image and you have to find what's wrong. You have to find the leaky valve. You have to find if one wall of the heart has thickened or one part of the wall has thickened. You have to find the part that no longer moves easily, no longer contracts. So the normal findings really don't make it into the report because they're normal. So you just say normal. But the job, the main job is to find the abnormality. A patient does the test to find out what's wrong so that hopefully they can fix it. And Dr. Emrani says that he studied very hard. He worked very hard. And within months he could spot the defect in seconds. He was very, very expert at being able to look at these scans and being able to find the problem right away. And then he noticed he writes, I had brought the machine home. He means this in a metaphoric sense, as you will see. At dinner, I saw the dish that was overcooked. On my child's report card, I saw the B before the five A's. In a friend's story, I heard the weak point in his logic before I heard his pain. I was becoming very good at finding what was wrong and steadily worse at being happy. That is, the training that he was doing medically was seeping over into his life where he's looking at these test results, looking for the defect, looking for what was wrong. And it started to infect other aspects of his life. And he explains this mission in Pricci Evo's. In our total portion, we have the famous narrative of Abraham negotiating with God to save the people of Sedom. God says to Avram, I'm going to wipe out the city of Sedom. They're wicked. Avram says, what if there are 50 righteous people there? What if there are 40? What if there are 10 righteous people there? Will you save the city because of the 10? Avram knew exactly what Sedom was. He knew exactly that most of the people there were terribly wicked. He did not pretend that the city was just a righteous city. He didn't try to convince God, they're not so bad. Don't do it. Leave them alone. And yet when God revealed the destruction of Sedom, Avram began searching. Can I find 50 good people? 45, 30, 20? Can I find 10 good people? In other words, Avram knew that he was looking at one of the darkest places on earth. He knew that to use the medical terminology, he was looking at the scan of a failing heart with terrible, terrible illness. But he was looking for the part that was still working. He was searching for the part that was still well and that could lead to healing. Billum was hired to do the reverse. You remember the narrative that we learned later on in the book of, the book of Numbers, the fourth book of the Torah, that Billum went to the top of one mountain overlooking the camp of the Jewish people and he tried to find fault with what he saw there to curse the Jewish people and he couldn't find it because there was goodness there and he couldn't find anything wrong. And then he went to another spot, the top of another mountain, with a different view and he was looking for what was wrong. He was looking for the disease, but he couldn't find it. He was looking for the place where a curse could somehow be affected, but he couldn't find it. And then the astonishing part, the supernatural part, is that though he truly looked for the bad, he truly looked for what was wrong, what came out of his mouth was a blessing. Matavu alechiyakov, how good are your tents, Yaakov. In other words, the good was there all along. And in the case of Billum, even though his eye in was raw, his eye was bad, was evil, he was looking for the evil, he was forced to see honestly and he could not deny the good that he saw. And so what Dr. Imrani says is that the difference between Avraham and Billum is not what they could see. They both saw the same world. Avraham could see the bad in Sedom and the good in Sedom. Billum could see the good in Israel and he tried to see the bad in Israel. The difference between the two of them is what they were searching for. Avraham's eye in Tove, his good eye, did not cause him to be oblivious to the darkness and the disease and the terrible aspects of Sedom. But he was searching for the good. Can I find 50 good people? Can I find 10 good people? That's what he was searching for. Billum was searching for weakness. Billum was searching for disease. Yes, he saw that there was goodness, but he was still searching for what was wrong. Dr. Imrani tells how what changed his view in his medical training and this then also carried over to his life. He learned when he saw his mentor, his teacher, who had so much more experience than him, who was even quicker than him at finding the defect. He watched carefully when this doctor presented the results to the patient and this doctor with more experience and more knowledge, he would sit down with the patient and he would explain the damage very plainly and then he would turn the screen on which the image was located. He would turn the image around so that the patient could see the defect, but then he would point in and he would say, now look at this part of the heart. Look at this wall of the heart. You see how it does move. You see how it is working. That muscle has been beating for however many years, for 78 years to take an example of one patient, 78 years old. That heart, that muscle has been beating for 78 years without a single day off and that part of your heart is still fighting for you. So yes, the other part has a defect, but we need to find the way to be able to make sure that the part that is beating, the part that is working, is going to be able to take control. Dr. Emrani says that as he sat with this much wiser doctor explaining to the patient what they saw on the image, I watched patients cry not at the diagnosis, but at being seen whole and walking out of an appointment with this doctor who is his mentor. The doctor said to him, any machine can find the defect. A healer finds what's still alive, what's working, what's good. The mission says that if we are among the Talmudim, the disciples of Avraham with an eye in Tova, an eye that though it sees that reality, including what is bad and disease, but looks for what is good. Arabi say that the result of that is, ochlin ba'olam hazeh. They will eat, they will enjoy what they eat in this world. What does that mean? Dr. Emrani says, I understand that now. The person who hunts for flaws goes hungry at every table because if you only search for flaws, you'll find the flaw in the dish, you'll find the flaw in the meal, you'll find the flaw in the person. You're going to go through life hungry. The person who hunts for life finds nourishment everywhere in a tired spouse, but look for the beauty in them in a struggling child, but search for their successes. A stranger on a screen, even in himself, if you're looking for what's right, you'll be able to eat and enjoy and be much happier, not because you are naive, not because you are oblivious to what needs to be fixed, but because you're searching for what is well, what is good. Dr. Emrani ends with a piece of advice. I share it with you and I share it with me tonight. Before you name what's wrong with someone, find one wall that's still moving, that's still working. Point to it and say it out loud. This part is good. This is working. This is healthy. Be a talmud of Avraham, not of Billam, because anyone can find a defect. A talmud of Avraham finds what's alive, finds what's good. My friends, I wish you a great day and I look forward to seeing you soon in person.